Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files 725

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.

Schillok takes over!!!

The woman poisoned him after her husband acted like he was breaking down (but was actually fine - both of them knew it was an act).
5
17%
The woman managed to smuggle the poison in/on his glass after he started drinking from it.
1
3%
The woman prepared a poisoned glass/object before the party and managed to make her husband take it.
13
45%
The woman poisoned her own drink and managed to exchange it for her husbands.
2
7%
The woman is not the culprit - she had an accomplice to do it for her.
1
3%
It is was an elaborate BO plot to kill the man - and noone will ever figure out the truth.
7
24%
 
Total votes: 29
Read and Gold Phoenix
Satou/Takagi <3

Posts:
128

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by Read and Gold Phoenix »

This case is sooo good! SATOU/TAKAGI LOVE <3
User avatar
caribou

Posts:
269
Contact:

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by caribou »

i've worked in a cafe before and i'd like to say that it would be near impossible to stick a peeled slice of lemon on a glass, it would be too wet and floppy to stay on. the peel does help to keep the shape, yes. :P and normally lemon slices are just put on drinks as a garnish, i think, i don't think people usually eat or even suck on them...

im quite clueless about the case this time around so i won't add anything more :X
"Shh! Celebrate after the curtain of this bloody stage closes."

Image
RedPoppy

Posts:
253

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by RedPoppy »

caribou wrote: i've worked in a cafe before and i'd like to say that it would be near impossible to stick a peeled slice of lemon on a glass, it would be too wet and floppy to stay on. the peel does help to keep the shape, yes. :P and normally lemon slices are just put on drinks as a garnish, i think, i don't think people usually eat or even suck on them...

im quite clueless about the case this time around so i won't add anything more :X
You're right, the lemon can't be peeled to keep its shape. I don't see anything weird in eating lemon. Some time ago I liked to suck lemon slices (unpeeled), later I found out that this acid in lemon can ruined my teeth, so I stoped doing that. But I don't think people usually do that on the parties, I guess it would look creepy. In current case I guess the victim just put the lemon inside his mouth to make good expression of being poisoned (he can't stand sour things), but he actually was poisoned by that lemon. The wife put the slice of lemon after his attack and then she threw it away. That's what I think. We will see if I was right or not.
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

The case seems to have gone down pretty much like I predicted, with some details wrong but the main framework correct. Lol, Kogoro is really starting to figure out the darting trick this time. He protects his neck, but get's shot in the forehead instead. Scary, scary. Midori getting drunk while angry at Megure is cute, especially when he reveals where her chocolate is. I totally didn't think she was the type to get herself sodded like that. A Megure romance case would be cute.  And Makoto appeared. I wish he would show up in a case... and too bad Kobayashi didn't appear.
Key-chan
Angels don't exist? Then you haven't met one yet.

Posts:
119

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by Key-chan »

RedPoppy wrote: Some time ago I liked to suck lemon slices (unpeeled), later I found out that this acid in lemon can ruined my teeth, so I stoped doing that.
It's true, but only if you do it too often. Doing it every now and then (for some reason I'm thinking once a month, go figure out why) can actually clean your teeth as well.

...Or so I heard :P
Image
(Rock'n'Roll-Shinichi ftw)
User avatar
shinichi1977

Posts:
68

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by shinichi1977 »

I put it out in this thread since though directly not a spoiler but a possible easter egg it should be here rather than in general discussion.

I was only a bit wondering why Aoyama broke the usual 25-chapter roaster of main plot related cases, but just recently I found he might have had recently put a possible sublime message in the story arc.

Sour mash is a distillation process invented and applied in Kentucky. It is neither the type or the flavor of the whisky. In the process the mixture of grain, malt and water is conditioned with previously alcohol-freed mash. The process is used in bourbon and Tennessee whiskey, one such brand is Maker's Mark.

I'm not saying that it is a metaphor for Akai getting rid of his former taint to evolve into something pure, or that it is real, just that it is possible, and if so can be interpreted as a clear distinction between Okiya and Bourbon
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

shinichi1977 wrote: I put it out in this thread since though directly not a spoiler but a possible easter egg it should be here rather than in general discussion.

I was only a bit wondering why Aoyama broke the usual 25-chapter roaster of main plot related cases, but just recently I found he might have had recently put a possible sublime message in the story arc.

Sour mash is a distillation process invented and applied in Kentucky. It is neither the type or the flavor of the whisky. In the process the mixture of grain, malt and water is conditioned with previously alcohol-freed mash. The process is used in bourbon and Tennessee whiskey, one such brand is Maker's Mark.

I'm not saying that it is a metaphor for Akai getting rid of his former taint to evolve into something pure, or that it is real, just that it is possible, and if so can be interpreted as a clear distinction between Okiya and Bourbon
I missed how the sour mash is related to this case and Gosho taking too bloody long to return to the plot...  ;)
User avatar
shinichi1977

Posts:
68

Re: Chekhov MacG Memorial Thread for White Day Murder (Files

Post by shinichi1977 »

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
shinichi1977 wrote: I put it out in this thread since though directly not a spoiler but a possible easter egg it should be here rather than in general discussion.

I was only a bit wondering why Aoyama broke the usual 25-chapter roaster of main plot related cases, but just recently I found he might have had recently put a possible sublime message in the story arc.

Sour mash is a distillation process invented and applied in Kentucky. It is neither the type or the flavor of the whisky. In the process the mixture of grain, malt and water is conditioned with previously alcohol-freed mash. The process is used in bourbon and Tennessee whiskey, one such brand is Maker's Mark.

I'm not saying that it is a metaphor for Akai getting rid of his former taint to evolve into something pure, or that it is real, just that it is possible, and if so can be interpreted as a clear distinction between Okiya and Bourbon
I missed how the sour mash is related to this case and Gosho taking too bloody long to return to the plot...  ;)
Well, of course it could have been over-thinking, just wanted to say that it did mention a pun on black spy, which might be a pour bourbon and the other one is getting distilled from it, like "getting reborn" but still has the core element.
Post Reply