ESPIONAGE: Campaign Round - DETECTIVES AND CIVILIANS WIN!

[Kaito Lady]

Oops! Looks like I'm a bit late to the party. Sorry guys, been a bit busy :V

So anyone still willing to exchange votes? XD

I'm willing to vote for you if you vote for me

[Jellitto]

I'm going to give one vote to five different players, not really knowing what else to do at this point.

[Osaka Detective]

Oops! Looks like I'm a bit late to the party. Sorry guys, been a bit busy :V

So anyone still willing to exchange votes? XD

I'm willing to vote for you if you vote for me

Sure, a one-one deal for today? XD

[Kaito Lady]

Oops! Looks like I'm a bit late to the party. Sorry guys, been a bit busy :V

So anyone still willing to exchange votes? XD

I'm willing to vote for you if you vote for me

Sure, a one-one deal for today? XD

Sure!

[Raiden]

whoa there. now, now... Let's get down to business~
dammit Raiden >.> xD

...to defeat the spies~ ♪♪
@reply: You're very welcome, SA! Keikaku doori! >:3

Spoiler: 8D

@Osaka Detektive: Willing to make the same deal you arranged with KL for the upcoming phase. ^_^

[Edogawa4869]

Spoiler: 8D

Spoiler: :P

Phoenix definitely should be in Kay's place right now.

[MoonRaven]

okay... I guess it's the time to vote now. Then I'm going to sleep. I wish luck to everyone.

[Stopwatch]

so... MDavid, "Who is the most suspicious of being a spy?"

At this moment it seems to be Fujiwara.

That will be (at least) 1 vote for me.

Why Fujiwara?

EDIT: It's just as important for us to assess your reasons for being susp of someone as it is for you to be susp of them in the first place. Revealing why they're susp in most cases won't give anything away given the setup and gives us the chance to see whether you might have a valid point. Just a name is almost worthless.

I'm feeling too lazy to read all the posts since I've been away. I'm just going to give out one vote per each person I'm voting quite randomly. If I rememebr correctly they are all from my list. I just hope some people will give votes to my direction too. 'kay?

...so you're basically admitting you're narrowing the Detective down?

Misguided Townie.

If you're going to vote on your list the last thing you should is to admit it. Just, change your votes or pretend you have, or you're giving away info that should not be given away.

[MDavid]

Why Fujiwara?

EDIT: It's just as important for us to assess your reasons for being susp of someone as it is for you to be susp of them in the first place. Revealing why they're susp in most cases won't give anything away given the setup and gives us the chance to see whether you might have a valid point. Just a name is almost worthless.

I understand your point, but for now I am sticking to my strategy. I don't want to become a target just yet. It's dangerous already, that's why I ask for votes in return. My calculation is only an innocent hint and I totally understand if you don't trust it at all.

Also as I mentioned multiple times, my database is dynamically changing. By now Fujiwara isn't even the most suspicious according to it. And no, I'm not saying this to get another vote by exploiting your curiosity.

[Edogawa4869]

DAY 1 HAS ENDED


Jd- ⇌ +9
Fujiwara ⇌ +9
shinichi'sapprentice ⇌ +7
Kaito Lady ⇌ +7
Jecka ⇌ +7
Iwamoto Yuri ⇌ +6
Raiden ⇌ +6
dumytru ⇌ +5
Stopwatch ⇌ +5
Togop ⇌ +4
MoonRaven ⇌ +3
Raifuujin ⇌ +3
MDavid ⇌ +3
darkest absol ⇌ +2
Nemomon ⇌ +2
Osaka Detective ⇌ +1
Jellitto ⇌ 0
Kamite ⇌ 0
k11chi ⇌ -4

RESULTS: Player k11chi (Civilian) has received the fewest votes and has been eliminated from the game. The next morning, Togop (Civilian) and darkest absol (Civilian) were found dead.


dumytru ↪ +1 MoonRaven, +2 Jd-, +1 Jellitto, +1 Stopwatch
shinichi'sapprentice ↪ +1 dumytru, +1 darkest absol, +1 Jecka, +1 Raifuujin, +1 MDavid, +1 Kamite, +1 Nemomon
Fujiwara ↪ +1 dumytru, +1 Iwamoto Yuri, +1 darkest absol, +1 Jd-, +1 Jellitto, +2 Osaka Detective, +1 Raiden, +1 Nemomon
Kaito Lady ↪ +1 Fujiwara, +1 Iwamoto Yuri, +1 darkest absol, +1 Jd-, +1 Jecka, +1 Osaka Detective, +1 Raiden
Iwamoto Yuri ↪ +1 Fujiwara, +2 Kaito Lady, +1 MoonRaven, +1 Raiden, +1 Stopwatch
darkest absol ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 MDavid
MoonRaven ↪ +1 Jellitto, +1 Kamite, +1 Nemomon
Jd- ↪ +2 dumytru, +1 Fujiwara, +1 Iwamoto Yuri, +1 MoonRaven, +2 Osaka Detective, +1 Stopwatch, +1 Nemomon
Jellitto ↪
Jecka ↪ +1 Iwamoto Yuri, +1 MoonRaven, +1 Jellitto, +1 Raifuujin, +2 Kamite, +1 Nemomon
Osaka Detective ↪ +1 Kaito Lady
k11chi ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, -5 k11chi
Raifuujin ↪ +1 Jecka, +2 Raiden
Raiden ↪ +1 Fujiwara, +2 Kaito Lady, +2 Jecka, +1 Raifuujin
Stopwatch ↪ +1 darkest absol, +1 Jellitto, +2 MDavid, +1 Kamite
Togop ↪ +1 dumytru, +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 Fujiwara, +1 darkest absol, +1 MoonRaven, +1 Jd-, +1 Raifuujin, +1 Stopwatch, +1 MDavid, -5 Togop
MDavid ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 Iwamoto Yuri, +1 Raifuujin
Kamite ↪
Nemomon ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 Stopwatch

[shinichi'sapprentice]

damn! and asdfghjkla;lwihrgrbwkjjOARUGNJKWARGNUWJKDS Togop and other moldy agent ;_;

wait... wth why did you not vote, Togop! >.>

i need to stare at the ballot report for a long time to gather my thoughts xD

i shall be back with my hyping idea

*disappears*

[Togop]

Sorry. I was unable to log in this morning .

*goes back to read all the old posts I've missed not that I'd be much help, being dead and all...*

[Jecka]

D: poor K11chi, Togop, and DA

[Jd-]

That's basically our worst-case-scenario...

What we know now is that both Spies are active and we can only hope that both Detectives are as well. There's unfortunately no guaranteed and safe way to communicate as Civilians with the Detectives, but we should definitely brainstorm (about ways that don't give them away to the Spies at any time before they potentially die).

It is a very good thing that we only had one player who didn't allocate their votes or this could be a much harder round for us to win. In fact, if k11chi had voted (and not for Kamite and Jellitto or had still balanced it between them), the result would've been a tie at 0 for two other players and no one would've been eliminated. I'll post more thoughts in a moment. Let me have a think first...

[shinichi'sapprentice]

notes-taking done.

thoughts...

well... i was gonna question those people who voted the three people who died day 1 but damn... xD

k11chi ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, -5 k11chi
darkest absol ↪ +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 MDavid
Togop ↪ +1 dumytru, +1 shinichi'sapprentice, +1 Fujiwara, +1 darkest absol, +1 MoonRaven, +1 Jd-, +1 Raifuujin, +1 Stopwatch, +1 MDavid, -5 Togop

first off. questioning the person who voted k11chi is useless since he died from having received the least number of votes. in this case... sadly,.. he died by his own hands. i'd gladly answer though if anyone still questions my vote

secondly... how dare you, spy, you, kill other moldy agent! >.> hey MDavid, care to explain your vote on her? ...i'll also gladly answer if anyone questions my vote

thirdly... Togop ;_; with those nine people who voted him... one can only wonder... did at least one of those people tried to sneak in a vote to avoid suspicions of killing him..?

here were my votes Day 1 for easy reading to anyone else who are taking down notes xD
+1 darkest absol
+1 k11chi
+1 Togop
+1 MDavid
+1 Nemomon

---

Now... A proposal...

In one day, we lost three people in an instant! One lucky shot and a spy could easily hurt us by ridding us of a detective. What is more frustrating is when a detective dies without even giving us a single clue to who he has proven NOT SPY. Fortunately, we still have both our two detective warriors around. 8D Now, we can't just leave everything to them, can we? Here's an idea...

By this time, there should be TWO PROVEN PEOPLE that are found out NOT SPIES. I think I can say this with 100% certainty since out of 19 players, there were only two people who weren't able to cast their votes. But sadly, those two people are now gone... With the others all able to cast each of their votes, it would be pointless if they weren't able to send an investigate Day 1, wouldn't it? Now, what happens if this day ends and we tragically lose a detective without them even being able to tell us who they have proven NOT SPY? Sad, isn't it? Anyway, here's the idea xD

Day 2, every single one of us will give out +2 votes to who we have proven NOT SPY. Now, how would that work... There are only two detectives after all... Well,.. How else of course but with the ancient art of bluffing. xD With 16 people remaining, how awesome would it be to confuse our two damned spies with 14 different people posing as a detective. Now, this isn't just a joke... If all of us allocate a +2 votes to a person we have proven NOT SPY,..
~It'll help List Owners narrow down who might be the detective that they should protect at all costs
~It'll help the real detectives hide their genuine results with so many people giving +2 votes to other people
~Spies can't really narrow down who's detective with this, can they?

Also, there's another way to lessen the risk of being narrowed down as detective. With five votes that one can give out, a detective can also hide their own genuine investigations by allocating two +2 votes to people. Of course, right now, they have only proven ONE person as NOT SPY. So... Example:
Day 2
I give +2 votes to Togop.
I give +2 votes to darkest absol.
I give +1 vote to k11chi.

Say, Togop was the one you have proven NOT SPY, you can give another +2 votes to another person to hide that. Even though you haven't proven the other one yet.

Though... there might be instances wherein the detective might have gotten a NOT SPY result on a person that has already passed... But what are the chances? xD That's why as mom said, I mean, this person, said... xD

Spoiler:

Anyway, I say this is a proposal but just like my ridiculous ditch day 1 idea, I seek the approval of no one and will go through with it.

Thoughts?