Werewolf #1

[shinichi'sapprentice]

other moldy Butz! D:

i didn't die. so, i'll get to post this

this is where i should be saying

Spoiler:

but

Spoiler:

now, Let's hunt some werewolves, shall we

i'm voting... and you thought i hid something here, didn't ya?

[MoonRaven]

I have no freaking idea who to vote...

[Osaka Detective]

We have 15 hours, I don't think it's exactly necessary to rush the vote right now, though I think we have to eventually come to a conclusion as to who we should vote.

Right now at this juncture, I think it's important that everyone speak up and contribute. In this other forum mafia game I played (which was more topic-board-discussion-based), many mafias attempt to steer clear of suspicion by posting as little as possible, which pretty much reduced their chances of slipping up and accidentally revealing a secret. Right now, I think it'd be helpful for people to speak and not to hide or anything xd I mean Day 1 is pretty painful with not even a clue to follow up with, so I'd understand if people choose to not talk, but still XP

Anyways, I think it's not exactly necessary to vote now. I'll be pausing it off until more people post and hopefully someone slips up something somewhere XD

[MoonRaven]

*is considering of going to the random number generator*

[Memesu]

I probably won't vote this phase.

[Osaka Detective]

So in about five hours it's phase change already, and we still have a few who hasn't said anything yet.

3) dumytru
5) KangarooGirl
7) Iwamoto Yuri
8) Kleene Onigiri
9) miyano_shiho
15) Kaldra

So while Werewolves don't necessarily have to be in the silent crowd, I think activity is something to take into account. I mean I know people have lives and all and I feel terrible for pointing them out so =p Still, I'm going to go along with it and throw the numbers into the pot of RNG, cross my fingers and go to bed.

Vote player: Kaldra

The RNG has spoken. Now to wake up tomorrow morning to proceed to get trucked because he/she has an important role xd;

[Fujiwara]

I would like to mention that there isn't anything like "nominations". I mean, while between Yourselves You can use this word, a vote is a vote, and each player may vote only for one player at a given time. He of course still can change that vote, but Game Master will never count something like this: "I vote for XXX and YYY".

Nominations come from Espionage. They're not meant to count as votes - it's just a way of putting people on the spot, so to speak.

Fine then. *Everyone* should contact other people so it doesn't become apparent who the Seer is and whoever thinks they have the role 'Seer' should make sure not to forget they could be the Fool.

I don't really see how a Villager finding out who the Seer is is a bad thing. If the Seer contacts a Villager, he can be sure that the person he contacts actually is a Villager and thus the other person is trustworthy.
It's the person who's being contacted, on the other hand, who can't be sure whether they were contacted by
a) the Seer,
b) the Fool, or
c) a Werewolf posing as the Seer

The Seer himself can, of course, also not be sure whether he's the Seer of the Fool, but in the end it's the person who is entrusted with the information who'll have to decide in how far to trust the person who contacted them and what to do with the info.

The other scenario is that the Fool may mistakenly contact a Werewolf, thinking that it's a Villager. In this case the Werewolf will know (or guess) that the person who contacted them is the Fool. That could be slightly advantageous, but that would probably be balanced out by the actual Seer contacting a Villager.

In conclusion, I don't see how the 'Seer' contacting a 'Villager' is a bad thing and why it would need to be camouflaged.

[MoonRaven]

In my opinion Seer/Fool should contact the villager but not necessary in this phase quite yet.

[Iwamoto Yuri]

I think we should try random voting for now... there's really not much to discuss at this point, is there?

[MoonRaven]

Okay, I went to the generator. I'm voting number 15 (Kaldra).

[miyano_shiho]

I don't think I'm gonna vote today. I'm also not against the Seer/Fool contacting a 'Villager'. The Fool will not always get wrong results, so his role can still help even a bit. I think alliances are very necessary to figure out who the Werewolves are.

[Stopwatch]

The results will be random. What you're saying is basically that a broken clock is right twice a day and really, would you rely on a broken clock to tell the time?

[Kaldra]

I was originally going to post a response to what Togop said explaining the seer/fool situation like how Fujiwara did.. but I am new to the forum so I didn't want to overstep my boundaries. As for the people voting for me, I can understand that when it comes to random voting it is best to vote for a silent person bc as werewolf/mafia/BO they are more likely to stay silent.

I don't have any information so I will refrain from voting rather than randomly vote a person (who are more likely to be a villager than werewolf).

[Fujiwara]

I vote Stopwatch.

Also, guys, maybe you'd like to reconsider lynching the new guy on Day 1? That'd be lovely.

[MoonRaven]

I can't help it was the first result from the random number generator!