The Great DC Opening Contest (Magic vs. As the Dew)

[c-square]

It's finally here!  This is the Opening Contest match we've all been waiting for!

Round 1, Match 14

Opening #27
Magic by Rina Aiuchi

vs.

Opening #28
As the Dew by Garnet Crow

This is your last chance to make your mark on round one!

(Click here to see the previous match)

[c-square]

Much thanks to Parkur and Walbuls for both proactively posting and sending me the links to the subtitled versions!!  Great minds think alike, eh!

So, here are the subbed openings:

Magic

As the Dew

Oh, and my vote's for Magic.  As much as I was getting tired of seeing Magic, it is a decent opening with good music and nice animation to go with it.  As the Dew's animation is also good (except maybe for the floating umbrellas), but the song's just not up to standard, IMHO.

[Tanner-kun]

as the dew for me w00the most resentending 

[Abs.]

As the Dew might be too new (i.e., not familiar) yet, but I bet my vote would go to Magic regardless.

[CTU]

Hard call. Tho I think I will have to go with Magic

[Girl19]

As the Dew

[Vylash]

too much ran, not enough haibara, and NO YUMI!  but, as the dew did bring back akemi, and produce the most epic bourbon pose yet, so as the dew gets my vote

[takiko]

As the Dew!

Well, the songs are not really suited as opening themes but As the Dew's animation is much much better.

[bluekaitou1412]

As the Dew gets my vote.

[kkslider5552000]

As The Dew easily. It fits the show more than most openings and is an amazing song. Plus it feels much cooler and more exciting than most OPs, animation-wise.

[Akonyl]

^ that

[xGinx]

As the Dew is much more cooler than Magic and many others but i think that this videos will be cooler for DC Opnening or Closing xD LOL (Specially the last one)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDgfj0ST4UE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZmiYGtuR2M

[Conia]

As the Dew is my vote.

[Walbuls]

As the Dew, just love the song a lot more.

[Sherlock3]

Hard choice but im gonna have to go with Magic
for me i just love the animation more in Magic,  and i've grown to like the song also.
But it could also be that As the Dew is still new so im not quite used to it yet!
But regardless my vote goes to Magic