Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
Post Reply

What is Sera Masumi's identity

Akai's sister (someone else)
80
75%
Akai's sister (FBI, CIA, or other law enforcement)
12
11%
Akai's sister (Black Org agent)
1
1%
Akai's sister and Bourbon
3
3%
Akai's sister (someone else)
4
4%
Bourbon
0
No votes
Black Org Agent (new)
0
No votes
Black Org Agent (known one in disguise)
0
No votes
Sister of Black Organization member (not counting Akai)
0
No votes
FBI
2
2%
CIA
0
No votes
Other agency (Interpol, PSIA, MI6...)
1
1%
New or rival Organization
0
No votes
Known character in disguise
0
No votes
Relative of other known character not mentioned above
2
2%
non-BO freelance assassin
0
No votes
High school girl only
1
1%
Someone else
1
1%
 
Total votes: 107
shihokudo
you'll protect me right?

Posts:
1044
Contact:

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by shihokudo »

Hmm...I think she might just be a high school girl. a very CURIOUS high school girl.
OR

As Akai's sister, she was put into Witness Protection Program because of sometihng that happened? perhaps to their parents and then they were separated because he joined FBI etc. and now she's trying to find him?
Image

I'm His therefore I Am
Dancing is like Walking
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

DCW has been on the sketch recently, so in the interest of redundant redundancy, I am posting a copy of the Sera speculation topic from DCW here.

Last updated (Apr 18 2012)

Index
[iurl=#a]Sera Masumi's identity [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#aa]Sera is Akai Shuuichi's sister[/iurl]
. . . .. . . .[iurl=#aa1]• Direct Evidence[/iurl]
. . . .. . . .[iurl=#aa2]• Literary device arguments[/iurl]
. . . .. . . .[iurl=#aa3]• Minor points - i.e. weak arguments[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#ab]Sera is not... [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#ab1]. . . .• A loyal member of the Black Organization[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#ab2] . . . .• Scar Akai[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#ab3] . . . .• The hat lady from the prescreening case[/iurl]
[iurl=#d]Sera's allegiance and occupation[/iurl]
[iurl=#b]Sera's Goal[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#b1]• Sera is looking for Akai[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#b2]• Sera is looking into Conan and the people around him[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#b3]• Sera specifically targeting Conan because she found out that
. . . . he and Akai had some sort of connection before Akai's disappearance[/iurl]
[iurl=#c]Sera's purpose in the plot[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c1]• Sera will drive Ran's suspicion[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c2]• Sera will come across Bourbon[/iurl]
[iurl=http://aa]Miscellaneous[/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c3]• Sera knows Conan is Shinichi. [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c4]• Sera's comment about deleting Haibara's picture. [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c5]• Why doesn't Sera go to the FBI for help finding Akai? [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c6]•Why doesn't Sera tell Conan who she is and that she wants to find Akai? [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c7]• If Sera is after Akai, why is she interested in Ai and Conan? [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c8]• Why would Okiya, if he is Akai, step up protection after hearing about and seeing Sera? [/iurl]
. . . .[iurl=#c9]• Why did Sera cry and say she was a bad girl in 814? [/iurl]
[iurl=#e]Old arguments[/iurl]

Sera Masumi's identity
Sera is Akai Shuuichi's sister

Direct Evidence

Sera and Akai's eyes match
Sera has bags under her eyes identical to Akai Shuuichi's. The "siblings with identical eye designs" has been done before with Eisuke and Hidemi.

Characters who know Akai think she is familiar
• Conan thinks she looks familiar and feels like she is not an enemy. (73-9 pg 11) She has some similar features to Akai Shuuichi, like the eyes and the wavy/kinky black hair. Akai was an ally so it makes sense Conan would have this impression.
• Camel, Jodie, and James Black think she looks familiar. (File 778-780) They are all familiar with Akai.

Sera's relocation history matches up with Akai's infiltration activities.
Sera lived in Japan until three years ago when her family moved to America. (V73-9 pg 2) This matches with the time when Akai was infiltrating the Organization five to two years ago. The family's move to America could be the FBI's attempt to protect them should something go wrong with Akai's infiltration.

Sera recognizes Scar Akai (who looks like Akai)
Sera's reaction to Scar Akai was one of recognition. She called Scar Akai "an old acquaintance" (she couldn't exactly come out and say "brother"). Later, Sera comments about "this person in the past who never laughed". "In the past" implies this person had an existence failure, like Akai who is supposed to be dead or had run off on a mission and never returned. Also Akai is not the laughing type. He was cold before Akemi died and is worse now.

Literary device arguments

Sera's name origin is a pun on the younger sister of Akai's name origin.
Sera Masumi's name is derived from to Mobile Suit Gundam character Sayla Mass (セイラ・マス ''Seira Masu''). Gosho references this in an interview. Akai's name is derived from Sayla Mass's older brother's name, Char Anzable. (Akai's name comes from the Mobile Suit Gundam character Char Aznable, whose nickname was the "Red (Akai) Comet", and Char's voice actor Shuuichi Ikeda (who is also Akai's voice actor). Additionally, his alias, Dai Moroboshi, comes from Char's real name, Casval Rem Deikun (sounds like Dai-kun in Japanese). Moroboshi can also mean falling star, another possible allusion to Red Comet.)

Minor points - i.e. weak arguments

Sera and Akai share some habits.
Both often wear headwear when the situation allows it. (Akai wears beanies, Sera various hats when not in school or uniform) Sera and Akai also share the habit of pocketing their hands. Neither are exclusive behaviors however.

Sera is knowledgable about law enforcement.
Sera has knowledge of law enforcement, even the Japanese law enforcement, which would be expected of someone who has a sibling in law enforcement whom she cares about.

Sera reacts to the FBI
She reacted when Conan introduced Camel as being part of the FBI. (File 778) Akai was in the FBI.

Sera reacts Okiya Subaru
Sera reacted strongly to Okiya Subaru, who may be the real Akai.

Sera is not...
A loyal member of the Black Organization
If Sera was a loyal member of the Black Organization, she should have identified Ai was Sherry and have reported or eliminated her. Sera seems to already know Conan's identity (see below), but she has not done anything to harm him. Also, she would have also been more cautious in front of Conan and speaking about how much she knew in front of Mouri Kogoro. Besides the picture of Haibara reflected in Agasa's glasses, she also revealed she had information that she collected previously on Agasa (knew about Agasa is advance of his introduction) [771.4]. She revealed that she had done research on the professor to Kogoro and Ran. Also, she overtly tested Conan's deductive abilities in her introductory case. If she was Conan's enemy, she would have concealed that she knew who he was [768.16] and what he was capable of [769.4] in advance to ensure she had an advantage and would have also been more subtle about testing Conan's abilities to avoid making him realize that she was testing him. She wouldn't nearly directly ask if Conan was the brains behind Kogoro either.[771.4] She also deleted the information she collected on Haibara. If she was a target, deleting the info doesn't make sense even if she isn't going to do anything to Haibara right away.
Also a hotel is not a very secure base of operations for a BO agent. People can enter and exit as they please as long as they have a card, which can be used to break in if copied or if Sera is impersonated. Why not use a better backstory so she work from a residence that provides more security for one's personal belongings?

Scar Akai
Sera appeared at the same time as Scar Akai in 801.

The hat lady from the prescreening case
Sera is not the lady in the hat who followed Yukiko and the Detective Boys on Akai's orders during the film prescreening case (chaps 417-419). Conan asked Takagi to stop by their car and ask them questions about whether they had been drinking and such to get them to stop following the gang. Takagi would have recognized her during her appearance case. Also the shadowlady with the hat was shown smoking. Conan probably would have noticed if Sera smelled of smoke because that would be unexpected for someone who is supposed to be high-school aged. Cigarette smoke smell is also difficult to get out of clothes and hair, and we already had a shot of Sera's apartment and there were no obvious signs of smoking so Sera must have kicked the habit temporarily if she was hat lady.

Sera's allegiance and occupation
Sera is most likely a high school girl on the side of Akai.

• Sera responded to Scar Akai as an acquaintance. (Assuming she mistook Scar Akai for the real deal.)
• Sera is most likely not an FBI agent because Camel did not outright recognize her. (File 778) She is also seems a bit young although she could be concealing her real age.
• She is well acquainted with the names and procedures of various elements of the Japanese law enforcement although she has been living in America for three years. That means she likely has a personal interest in law enforcement for some reason.
• In the process of investigating Conan, she discovered Shinichi Kudo is alive. She also obtained an image of Haibara and her current address. She has made no moves against either party, suggesting she is not part of the Organization.
• Sera seems to already know Conan's identity (see below), but she has not done anything to harm him.

Sera's Goal
Sera is trying to locate Akai Shuuichi or is trying to find out why he died, and she is doing so by looking into the people connected with Conan.

Sera is looking for Akai
If Sera is Akai's sister, as argued above, it would make sense for her to wonder what happened to him or investigate his supposed death. This parallels the situation with Eisuke and Hidemi.
• Sera chases after Scar Akai when she seems him, and calls him "an old acquaintance." If she thinks Scar Akai is the real Akai or someone who looks exceedingly like him, her reaction clearly suggests she is interested in Akai. Later, Sera comments about "this person in the past who never laughed". "In the past" implies this person had an existence failure, like Akai who is supposed to be dead or had run off on a mission and never returned. Also Akai is not the laughing type. He was cold before Akemi died and is worse now.
• Sera revealed she had taken a special interest in Okiya Subaru before the Detective Boys informed her about them. She specifically was wondering if someone had just moved in to the Kudo household without permission, indicating that she is interested in a person who might just move in.
• She also asks about Agasa's living situation. After learning via Genta and Mitsuhiko that the only occupants were the professor and Haibara, she discards some of the information she collected on them, possibly indicating they were no longer of interest because Akai or someone who could be Akai was not living there.
• Sera comments that "Deletion. For data at least ... is an easy task to accomplish." (File 777 pg 16) Although Sera was deleting a picture of Haibara from her computer at the time, it could be interpreted as a general comment that while data is easy to erase, it is much harder to erase traces of someone in real life. By implication that would reveal she is interested in someone who had been "erased", like Akai for example.
• Sera takes a special interest when Conan reveals Camel is an FBI agent. This suggests that her motive involves the FBI.

Sera is looking into Conan and the people around him
Sera knows about Conan and is specifically looking into him and the people around him. She knew Conan's name in advance without being told and that he was a detective in his own right. She likely thinks Conan is the force behind sleeping Kogoro after asking Kogoro a pointed question about Conan being by Kogoro's side for all his cases. She specifically tries to meet with Conan and talk to him on at least one occasion. She also deliberately messed up the explanation to a case, seemingly in order to test Conan's deduction ability.
Sera has also investigated the people around Conan. She asks various people probing questions. She actively collected and stored data on her computer about Agasa. She also knows information about people in advance indicating she has done research. She knew Ran was a a high level karate practitioner when they met. In file 771, it is revealed that she also knows Professor Agasa, although she calls him "Professor whatshisname" at first. She looked up a video of Agasa's online and managed to get an image of the video taker Haibara by zooming in on his glasses. She also went to visit Agasa's house and asked Mitsuhiko and Genta about the person living in the Kudo house and Agasa and Haibara.

Sera specifically targeting Conan because she found out that he and Akai had some sort of connection before Akai's disappearance
As for how she found out about Conan and Akai's relationship, I think she acquired some of Akai's pictures of Conan and Haibara from when Akai was investigating them in the Vermouth arc. Specifically Akai had one of the Detective Boys as they were about to enter a film studio with Yukiko. This would explain why she targets Ai at all; she was quite prominent in the picture and thus possibly Akai's person of interest. As for how she got it, Akai kept the one of Shiho (with Conan, the DB, and Yukiko in the background) as a personal memento and the FBI overlooked it when sending his things back to America after he "died". This is plausible because Akai kept it in his truck, but it is no longer there during the events of Red vs. Black, and the police obviously didn't find it in the glove compartment or Takagi would have asked Conan about it.
Image
She could have also grilled someone in the FBI. A bunch of FBI agents saw Conan and Akai together in the strategy meeting. The way Conan and Akai were interacting made it clear that they knew each other and had been planning together. Camel and Jodie didn't recognize her though.

Sera's purpose in the plot
I think it is extremely likely the climax of the Bourbon arc will involve a simultaneous confrontation with Bourbon and Ran suspects Conan plot. Sera is a catalyst to drive both of these forward.

Sera will drive Ran's suspicion
Sera's suspicion of Conan will drive Ran to suspect Conan is Shinichi either by directly wondering about the possibility to Ran, but more likely by uncovering something that makes Ran suspicious. Back during the Shiragami case (V62 chaps 650-651), Heiji used Shinichi's fingerprints on his omamori as evidence to show "Shinichi" was a plastic surgery lookalike. Shinichi/Conan's fingerprints got on Heiji's omamori in the first place when Conan pulled the handcuff link pieces out of the bag to show Ran that they blocked Numabuchi Kiichiro's stabbing attempt (V19-F8 188 pg 8). Ran remembers this incident in the sports bar case (V66-F8 693 pg 11), and asks Kazuha about the discrepancy: she knows Conan handled the omamori a long time ago, but when did Shinichi handle it? Note that this situation closely parallels the question of Akai's fingerprints on Conan's cellphone (and Conan may try to resolve it in a similar fashion.)
Sera seems to already have uncovered Conan is Shinichi. (801 and see Miscellaneous section below) She also asks Ran to bring some photo albums, which Shinichi will be in, because she wants to see what Shinichi looks like to confirm her suspicions. She is already "pointing" Ran to some evidence that will make her suspicious.

Sera will come across Bourbon (Edit: Already happened!)
I think it is likely Sera will run into scar Akai, who is Bourbon is disguise, and mistake him for the real Akai. Either she will try to find or make contact with scar Akai herself, necessitating intervention by Conan and Akai (disguised as Okiya), or Bourbon will attempt to use her to lure the real Akai out or kill her, also necessitating intervention by the same two.
Sera meeting with Okiya and uncovering that he is Akai would be a dead end plotwise unless Sera is being followed. In the Eisuke arc, Conan was suspicious that Eisuke was unknowingly being used by the Org to find Hidemi, but that turned out not to be the case. If Bourbon knows about Sera, then he could be using her as an unwitting bait for Akai, and in the process of following her stumble across her investigation of Conan and take interest in it himself, leading to the showdown with him.
In any case, Sera's presence will trigger Akai to do something once he finds out she is in Japan looking into his death/disappearance. Akai doesn't have much of a choice because Sera is investigating Conan and Shinichi which will and has brought her to Shinichi's house once already. Akai can't ask the FBI to help since they think he is dead, also with Bourbon wandering around looking like scar Akai, he has to do something to protect her before she meets scar Akai and becomes a target.

Miscellaneous Arguments

Sera knows Conan is Shinichi.
Sera has demonstrated overt suspicion of Conan's talents, but her thought she "had known that for a long time" after Ran mentions Conan, just like Shinichi, is a Holmes addict suggests Sera knows his identity. She also asks Ran to bring photo albums of Shinichi, which will contain pictures of Shinichi when he is young. Sera can easily find pictures of Shinichi on the internet, but not Shinichi's past pictures, which suggest verification of her theory is her motive for wanting to see the album.
Sera also takes interest when Sonoko describes Haibara as a introverted woman trapped in the body of a small child who overlaps a lot with Conan.

Sera's comment about deleting Haibara's picture.
It's obviously an attempt by Gosho to make Sera look suspicious without having her do anything that logically deserves suspicion. Sera comments that "Deletion. For data at least ... is an easy task to accomplish." (File 777 pg 16) Although Sera was deleting a picture of Haibara from her computer at the time, it could be interpreted as a general comment that while data is easy to erase, it is much harder to erase traces of someone in real life. By implication, that would reveal she is interested in someone who had been "erased", like Akai for example.
She most likely erased the picture of Haibara because she ruled out Agasa's house as somewhere Akai might be living. After talking with Mitsuhiko and Genta in 775, she finds out no one else is living there besides the professor and Haibara. As Akai isn't there, she deletes the info she collected because she doesn't need it any more. If it isn't useful and someone might become suspicious of what she was doing if it was accidentally seen, there is no reason to keep it around.

Why doesn't Sera go to the FBI for help finding Akai?
If Sera is looking for Akai, why doesn't she scope the FBI, tell them who she is, or ask them for help? In summary, they might send her back or block any investigation she might make.
Besides being a civilian who shouldn't be involved, Sera is also a high risk one at that. Her identity as Akai's sister may mean the Org could try to use her as leverage against the FBI or as Akai, or kill her because of her relation to Akai. Anyone in the Org with a personal vendetta against Akai (like Bourbon) would also go after her.
Sera, assuming she thinks Akai is alive, doesn't know if the FBI knowingly faked Akai's death, or Akai did it on his own and tricked the FBI. If it was the first case, Sera would expect that she would be sent back immediately because the FBI would not want to have their operation endangered by her snooping around. In the second case, Sera would expect that they would send her back because of the danger she is putting herself and the FBI in. Also, if the FBI think Akai is dead, she wouldn't have much help from them anyway because they wouldn't tell her anything because it would be involving a civilian and they want to keep the Org investigation secret.

Why doesn't Sera tell Conan who she is and that she wants to find Akai?
Her task would become substantially harder if Conan decided to exclude her because it means she has laid all her cards on the table. She doesn't know how Conan will react which means telling him would be taking a gamble on him excluding her or informing the FBI she is in Japan to get her sent back. In any case, Conan would exclude her no questions asked because he is harboring Akai and she thus a liability. Conan locked down on Eisuke the moment he realized he might be connected to Rena and did as much as he could to avoid doing anything Eisuke would be interested in. That lockdown didn't let up even when Conan decided that Eisuke was probably not an enemy (nail and hammer case) because Conan was still worried that Eisuke could be used by the Org, and it could be the same deal with Sera.
Right now, Conan knows Sera is suspicious, but doesn't know what her goal is. If he knew she was looking for Akai, he could make various arrangements to make it harder for her to find out. As he doesn't know how to block her investigation, he can't take any targeted measures to dissuade her other than not tell her anything relevant.

If Sera is after Akai, why is she interested in Ai and Conan?
My suspicion is that she knew to look into Conan and Ai in the first place because she saw Akai's pictures of Conan and Haibara from when Akai was investigating them in the Vermouth arc. Specifically Akai had one of the Detective Boys as they were about to enter a film studio with Yukiko. This would explain why she targets Ai; she was quite prominent in the picture and thus possibly Akai's person of interest.
I assume she looked into everyone in the photo. Conan would come out prominently because of his involvement with Kaito Kid, and from there Sera started digging, like Eisuke, and noticed Conan's appearance correlated to Mouri's rise. Yukiko's presence ties in Kudo Shinichi, which explains why she takes interest in his name and when Conan used his name for a case. Sera wouldn't have asked Kogoro if Conan was around when he solved cases if she didn't make nearly the same connections that Eisuke did. In order to get anywhere, Eisuke had to hang around Ran and take advantage of Conan's love of cases. From Sera's perspective, Conan is going to be more interesting than anything she could dig up on Ai who has done an excellent job of keeping her public records unremarkable.
As for how she got the pictures, they don't have to get sent to her in particular, they could have been sent home, the way a dead soldier's personal effects get sent back. While the FBI can't get ahold of the body or Chevy because they are in police custody as murder victim John Doe and his stuff, the FBI might send back everything where Akai was shacking up and the picture was in his personal possessions. While the FBI would have kept mission related info, Akai may have kept the picture hidden somewhere personal because it was one of Shiho Miyano and meant something to him. The FBI overlooked it when they went through his things.

Why would Okiya, if he is Akai, step up protection after hearing about and seeing Sera?
Please see this post.

Why did Sera cry and say she was a bad girl in 814?
Sera's crying started when she she watched Ran putting a band aid on Conan. Although this is only a hunch, I have a feeling that watching them triggered a recollection of something very similar that happened between her and Akai when they were younger. As for why she says she is a bad girl, I do not know. The meaning and context are pretty vague so there are lots of possibilities.

Old Arguments

Sera is not Scar Akai
Sera didn't know Camel was an FBI agent until the restaurant case where he appeared. [778.11] Scar Akai, assuming he has been targeting FBI agents in his appearances, would have known Camel is an FBI agent after the Beika department store bomb scare.
Even if he didn't know before, Scar Akai would know Camel is an FBI agent from the way that Jodie was interacting with him in the Beika Dept store. If Scar Akai was following them earlier, he might have noticed Jodie introducing Camel as "Agent Camel" to Ran and Kogoro. Also, considering the two of them together, it's a pretty easy deduction to make, especially if Jodie is dragging Camel around to interrogate salespeople about a hat scar Akai knows to be his. (Which implies Jodie is looking for info on Akai, and Camel is party to this.) Also Scar Akai may have very well seen Jodie, Camel, and James Black together pre-Teito bank heist while picking the right moment to appear in front of Jodie. If Sera is Scar Akai, she would have at least strongly suspected Camel was FBI by the time Conan introduced Camel in the Danny's case. Her reaction isn't like that though; it's a just found out reaction. "Oh? FBI, huh..." Because Sera was thinking it instead of saying it aloud, there was no reason for her to "lie" in her head, because that wouldn't make any sense and Gosho never lies to the readers.
Last edited by Chekhov MacGuffin on May 9th, 2013, 1:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.
hidden ninja

Posts:
12

Sera & Haibara .... sisters in law !!! could it be ?

Post by hidden ninja »

well... the title is talking about itself, since gosho lately start to make some (strange) scenes between Okiya (akai) and haibara, it will not be surprised if we see them together at the end and that will make sera & haibara sisters in law
so what about you guys , how does this ending seems to you ?
Eclipse

Posts:
74
Contact:

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Eclipse »

Really interesting topic! I'll read it all when I'll have time, and I'm okay with the idea than Sera is Akai's sister, but it seems to be too easy, don't you?

~

About hidden ninja's idea of Sera could be Ai's sister :

*o* I really don't think about that, and I would think how Ai could have another sister and don't know her? If it's true, she don't know Sera is her sister, but I like the idea ^^ It seems more probable that Sera is Akai's sister (because of the eyes and the talk about somebody who "never smile", so...) but why not, why not ^^

What about you guys?

Ah, I just understood, sister in law... Such an odd idea ^^
Last edited by Eclipse on May 22nd, 2012, 5:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
HolmesA
http://blogdetectiveconan.blogspot.com.es/

Posts:
7

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by HolmesA »

Well, first of all I'd like to introduce myself as a new member here, in DCTP Forums. I'm HolmesA or Holmes' Apprentice. Nice to meet you guys!!

I think Sera has some connection with the BO, although it might not be directly. Being only Akai's sister (assuming that she is XD)... it is not such an important role for her. Or she's Bourbon (which I refuse since Ai didn't feel the BO scent the first time she saw her) or she's related to someone or something important in DC (the BO would be nice...). I don't know but, if it happens to be that she's only Akai's sister, it'll be weird since Gosho used something similar in Kirs' Arc with Eisuke.
About my bad English, I hope you'll forgive me!  (I am Spanish so... you see, I make mistakes XD)
User avatar
AICHAN
Curry time!

Posts:
2301

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by AICHAN »

HolmesA wrote: Well, first of all I'd like to introduce myself as a new member here, in DCTP Forums. I'm HolmesA or Holmes' Apprentice. Nice to meet you guys!!

I think Sera has some connection with the BO, although it might not be directly. Being only Akai's sister (assuming that she is XD)... it is not such an important role for her. Or she's Bourbon (which I refuse since Ai didn't feel the BO scent the first time she saw her) or she's related to someone or something important in DC (the BO would be nice...). I don't know but, if it happens to be that she's only Akai's sister, it'll be weird since Gosho used something similar in Kirs' Arc with Eisuke.
About my bad English, I hope you'll forgive me!  (I am Spanish so... you see, I make mistakes XD)
Welcome in DCTP forum^^Don't worry your english is good ;)

Concerning Sera,I really wonder if she has some kind of role she has in the BO plot,beside being Akai's sister.
I think she may be related to Shinichi in some way,but with the BO,I really doubt about that.
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Image
mangaluva wrote:
"I've built a wall not to keep people out, but to see who loves me enough to climb over it."
[/quote]
User avatar
Female Apprentice
Member of Loki's Fangirl - Army

Posts:
33

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Female Apprentice »

^^Hello Holmes' Apprentice  :)

I agree with Chekhov, since her arguments were logical and she gave proof for her theories.
And for me, it doesn't even look so complicated (which doesn't mean I'm sure about myself  ;) )
But Sera can't be FBI because neither Jodie nor Camel recognize her (http://www.dctp.ws/V74-Reader/V74-6Read/A8.html)
She can't be CIA since she doesn't seem to be interested in Hidemi or Eisuke, but in Conan/Shinichi (and she reacted to Okiya)
http://www.dctp.ws/V77-Reader/V77-8Read/A4.html
And she can't be BO because she reacted surprised when she saw Scar Akai. She could have destroyed some plans by just running to another member if she was a BO herself. (Can't find the picture right now, sorry  :()

So, together with Chekhov's theories, Sera being Akai's sister sounds very logical to me.  :)
Image
I believe I can flyyyyyyyyyyyyy~
HolmesA
http://blogdetectiveconan.blogspot.com.es/

Posts:
7

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by HolmesA »

Thank you so much for your nice welcome, really  :D
I respect a lot Chekhov's theories, in fact, I read them all and I agree with most of them XD But I think she (Sera) doesn't have to be a BO member herself to have some connection to them (besides being Akai's sister). But that's only my opinion ;)
Anyway, let's see what happens in the end with Sera's purposes ! ;D
Silver1412
No, I'm not sarcastic. I'm sarCATic ~nya.

Posts:
421

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Silver1412 »

Well her identity is now resolved... But why did she come to Japan? And what role will she play n the end?
~nya!
"Oh, don't give me that! None of you are saints, some of you are just good at hiding your sins!" - Our grade school teacher ~nya... She REALLY believed in our innocence didn't she
Image
The resident DCTP mother kitty ~nya!

DCTP Cat Family
Join us, you know you want to ~nya!
Avatar the courtesy of brilliant Yuri Iwamoto ~nya.
Spoiler: Sad truth about Mass Effect
Image
Feb914

Posts:
95

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Feb914 »

maybe she wanted to look for her brother. and somewhere somehow he can make connections between Conan and him, and decided to start looking by pegging to the Mouris.

I don't think she's part of any agency, she's a bit too naive for that, she doesn't try to hide her trail or motivation whatsoever.
Partsu
I'm always seeing the future that won't be...

Posts:
417

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Partsu »

I think we can lock Masumi and Shuuichi names ...now we need their surname REAL SURNAME...

anyway I still want her to be bourbon because she'd have to be really screwed up in the head to be one...
her character so far almost screams "good person" so yeah...
Spoiler:
though I want her to be Shuuichi's sister and bourbon I think she'll be just his sister and high school girl.
and Amuro'd be bourbon...and okiya is akai
Spoiler: things
Haibara for the win!
Certified
AokoxKaito/Kid,
Shinichi/ConanxRan,
KazuhaxHeiji-Fan
ShinConxRanxShiAi-for laughs
"There is only one truth"
and no one wants Ran to know it
...
bastards!
Image

Thank you briggettkylie for these amazing Gifs:
Spoiler: gifs
ImageImage
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

I guess she wasn't lying about her given name because I think she wouldn't have responded like that to Vermi Scar Akai using her alias. I was wondering if her real name was going to be something based off of "Artesia". It seems "Akai Masumi" will be her real name, unless "Akai" is an alias too. There is no clear indication Akai is an alias so...
Fennec

Posts:
109

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Fennec »

There are plenty of valid reasons to have different surnames. Most likely, Sera Masumi is an alias. If she's here to investigate her brother's disappearance, as cited in one of the above posts, she really wouldn't want the FBI to figure out her name. The name "Akai" would DEFINITELY trigger alarm bells in people's heads, even without the resemblance. Since the resemblance is most notable in the eyes—and even then, Masumi's eyes are bigger—it will be harder to pick up on her. Also, they could have divorced parents, or be half-siblings (in this case, it would be the mother).
fredinalnumber

Posts:
23

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by fredinalnumber »

Hey guys I wanna ask something. Is it safe to say that Sera is definitely Akai's sister based on Sera calling Scar Akai as Shuu-nii (which I think is short for Shuichi-niisan) in the last panel of File 821?
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Sera Masumi identity, motive, whatever speculation topic

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

fredinalnumber wrote: Hey guys I wanna ask something. Is it safe to say that Sera is definitely Akai's sister based on Sera calling Scar Akai as Shuu-nii (which I think is short for Shuichi-niisan) in the last panel of File 821?
I doubt she'd lie under the circumstances so I think it is a safe call at this point, especially since she isn't with the Black Organization assuming Scar Akai is BO (Vermouth) and confronting Sera for some plot. The wiki decided it was good enough to make official.
Last edited by Chekhov MacGuffin on June 15th, 2012, 9:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply