Age of Edogawa?

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
User avatar
Evil-eyed Yawny Girl
"Not assistant, we're partners."

Posts:
9

Age of Edogawa?

Post by Evil-eyed Yawny Girl »

The wiki's said he's 6-7 years old. But what episode did Conan said he's already 10 or did  he said that? Sorry, I think this is non sense but I'm curious and can't sleep till I know the answer. hehe
Last edited by Evil-eyed Yawny Girl on May 4th, 2012, 12:31 am, edited 1 time in total.
Image

Case closed! ;)
User avatar
aly_angelflight
Get that squirrel!

Posts:
577

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by aly_angelflight »

Uh, no, he's been saying he was 7 for a while now. ^^;
Image
"I suppose he could have changed. I myself have noticed my growing resemblance to a daffodil.”
3DS Friend Code: 2723-9258-9521
User avatar
Evil-eyed Yawny Girl
"Not assistant, we're partners."

Posts:
9

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by Evil-eyed Yawny Girl »

Ohh. Thank you so much! I think I just heard that 10 yrs old in my dreams. :)
Image

Case closed! ;)
ShinRan4ver

Posts:
568

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by ShinRan4ver »

This was in a recent AO, but in the red leaf mystery case he said he was 7. He don't get asked about age that often.
User avatar
Evil-eyed Yawny Girl
"Not assistant, we're partners."

Posts:
9

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by Evil-eyed Yawny Girl »

Oh! Thanks for the AO thing, I think I remember now. ;)
Image

Case closed! ;)
User avatar
Borealis

Posts:
801

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by Borealis »

*facepalm*
I thought the title referred to Age of Conan.....
*facepalm*
*facepalm*
*shot by grammar police*

 . ____
./        \
|    o    |
.\____./
      |_-,
     O
ShinRan4ver

Posts:
568

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by ShinRan4ver »

Evil-eyed Yawny Girl wrote: The wiki's said he's 6-7 years old. But what episode did Conan said he's already 10 or did  he said that? Sorry, I think this is non sense but I'm curious and can't sleep till I know the answer. hehe
I ran into this when rewatching episode 411, at the 02:10 mark Conan remakred that he is not 10 anymore, but he is talking about the fact that Shinichi is actually 17, not about Conan's age. In the manga version(V48-File 1-page 2) he simply said he is not a kid anymore, again talking as Shinichi, not Conan.
Last edited by ShinRan4ver on May 5th, 2012, 5:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
M.Holmes

Posts:
53

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by M.Holmes »

Slightly off-topic, but if there was one thing I could change about the series, it'd be the fact that time seems to have stopped (he'd have to be solving a ton of cases per day if it actually hasn't been over a year yet canonically).

I realize it might be a slight logistical headache for Gosho, but it'd make the series a lot more immersive (a preteen detective boys would be quite entertaining) and we'd know if the drug nullified the effects of aging (possibly a reason he isn't doing the series that way). I'd be interested to hear a question regarding the canonical time progression come up during one of his interviews - then we'd know more.
"It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts."
User avatar
aly_angelflight
Get that squirrel!

Posts:
577

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by aly_angelflight »

M.Holmes wrote: Slightly off-topic, but if there was one thing I could change about the series, it'd be the fact that time seems to have stopped (he'd have to be solving a ton of cases per day if it actually hasn't been over a year yet canonically).

I realize it might be a slight logistical headache for Gosho, but it'd make the series a lot more immersive (a preteen detective boys would be quite entertaining) and we'd know if the drug nullified the effects of aging (possibly a reason he isn't doing the series that way). I'd be interested to hear a question regarding the canonical time progression come up during one of his interviews - then we'd know more.
I believe he said DC runs on "Sazae-san" time (a.k.a. "Time progression? Pfft, who cares about that? This is lasting as long as it lasts, time be damned. ::)") in an interview... so I don't think Gosho is really keeping that much track of how much time has passed in the canon. ^^;
Image
"I suppose he could have changed. I myself have noticed my growing resemblance to a daffodil.”
3DS Friend Code: 2723-9258-9521
User avatar
M.Holmes

Posts:
53

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by M.Holmes »

aly_angelflight wrote:
M.Holmes wrote: Slightly off-topic, but if there was one thing I could change about the series, it'd be the fact that time seems to have stopped (he'd have to be solving a ton of cases per day if it actually hasn't been over a year yet canonically).

I realize it might be a slight logistical headache for Gosho, but it'd make the series a lot more immersive (a preteen detective boys would be quite entertaining) and we'd know if the drug nullified the effects of aging (possibly a reason he isn't doing the series that way). I'd be interested to hear a question regarding the canonical time progression come up during one of his interviews - then we'd know more.
I believe he said DC runs on "Sazae-san" time (a.k.a. "Time progression? Pfft, who cares about that? This is lasting as long as it lasts, time be damned. ::)") in an interview... so I don't think Gosho is really keeping that much track of how much time has passed in the canon. ^^;
I figured as much, but a man can dream!
"It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts."
User avatar
zek

Posts:
25

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by zek »

Still I would of thought he'd be 8 by now.
akki07

Posts:
10

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by akki07 »

guys, it's manga after all. Time is not the main issue, but the story

If you are really interested in working out Conan's age... I give you some hints
Spoiler:
reference = ch189 (volume 20), DBoys discussing about Football World Cup in France, that is in 1998. Moreover, the reference to Doha 4 years earlier on tells that in 1994 Edogawa was supposed to be 3 and in 1998 he was 7.
I am lazy to quote from all the DC series, but one fact would suggest that events occurring right now should be in early 2011: the smartphone technologies. Conan is seen using Sony Ericsson's Xperia series, and the one he has is being released in early 2011...
to his 7 in 1998, you add 13 from 1998-2011.... and the result says Conan should be in his 20's by now... but in the manga series, time is not given big importance as usual....
User avatar
shubhoshinichi
[DCTP] - Community's Logical Wizard.

Posts:
157
Contact:

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by shubhoshinichi »

Well, as the series began in sometime around 1994, at that time he was 7.. So, logically he must be 18+7 = 25 by now. But believe me he's still just 7.
When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.

And Ofc. There is always only one truth!


At last.. Be yourself always, always put a smile, be happy .. cause we're not the one to decide when our smile vanishes. . . Forever..

***ThIs Is My WoRlD!!!
                                       GET HYPE!!!
akki07

Posts:
10

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by akki07 »

shubhoshinichi wrote: Well, as the series began in sometime around 1994, at that time he was 7.. So, logically he must be 18+7 = 25 by now. But believe me he's still just 7.
I don't recall any information which would let people guess the timeline prior to ch189. So you would never know if the series should be located in 1994. For what we knew back then, author might have be telling a future story as well. The first time-based information should be the 98' World Cup in ch189 =)  For that reason, i don't feel like giving those years to conan actual age XD let him stay younger ;)
Mr. Flix
evil-eyed-yawny-boy | Ava by YURI! Thanks =3

Posts:
105

Re: Age of Edogawa?

Post by Mr. Flix »

At least in the german manga, Shinichi is holding a newpaper from 12. January 1994 in the first volume... But I assume that that is not in the original version, is it?
Post Reply