Who's the smartest?

Discussion relevant to everyone's favorite "Phantom Thief" happens here.
Locked

Who's the smartest among these Detective Conan list of characters?

Shin'ichi Kudou/Conan Edogawa
61
34%
Kaitou Kid
24
13%
Heiji Hattori
3
2%
Shuuichi Akai
7
4%
Okiya Subaru
1
1%
Ai Haibara
13
7%
Sharon Vineyard
0
No votes
Yuusaku Kudou
47
26%
Gin
6
3%
Mitsuhiko, Genta, Ayumi
1
1%
Kogoro Mouri
4
2%
Hiroshi Agasa
0
No votes
Sato Miwako
1
1%
Eisuke Hondou
2
1%
Hakuba Saguru
2
1%
Myself
9
5%
Others
1
1%
 
Total votes: 182
User avatar
bluekaitou1412
Community Phantom
Indie artist. Likes books and all things Haibara.

Posts:
5389

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by bluekaitou1412 »

But we don't know the IQ of the other characters.
Still-- voted Kaito.
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by Eve »

Hmmm.... Uhhh... in what field? I mean isn't it depends in the field they are working at? Or is it in term of IQs? ....

Because then Gosho Aoyama is the Smartest!!!!!!! XDDDD LOL

*shot and died for the day *
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
takiko

Posts:
1107

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by takiko »

Khinkhun wrote: Hmmm.... Uhhh... in what field? I mean isn't it depends in the field they are working at? Or is it in term of IQs? ....

Because then Gosho Aoyama is the Smartest!!!!!!! XDDDD LOL

*shot and died for the day *
yeah... it was very smart of him to make intelligent characters... and how on earth did he come up with those mind-boggling crimes, codes, etc?? :D
User avatar
bluekaitou1412
Community Phantom
Indie artist. Likes books and all things Haibara.

Posts:
5389

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by bluekaitou1412 »

takiko wrote:
Khinkhun wrote: Hmmm.... Uhhh... in what field? I mean isn't it depends in the field they are working at? Or is it in term of IQs? ....

Because then Gosho Aoyama is the Smartest!!!!!!! XDDDD LOL

*shot and died for the day *
yeah... it was very smart of him to make intelligent characters... and how on earth did he come up with those mind-boggling crimes, codes, etc?? :D
Because I'm his mentor.
Kidding. (obviously)
User avatar
AICHAN
Curry time!

Posts:
2301

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by AICHAN »

like some people said ,aoyama is the smartest!!! to find  all these trick to commit a murder,he's a pure genius!!!
by the way i voted for Ai/shiho!seriously,create a drug like that ,at 18,she's a genius!she also can solve murders(like in vol 21...)if she want seriously,but conan is more skilled for that(same thing with yusaku,heiji...)
i think most of people in this thread are very smart but in different way and different categories!
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Image
mangaluva wrote:
"I've built a wall not to keep people out, but to see who loves me enough to climb over it."
[/quote]
KaitoKid0
Banned.

Posts:
216
Contact:

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by KaitoKid0 »

AICHAN wrote: like some people said ,aoyama is the smartest!!! to find  all these trick to commit a murder,he's a pure genius!!!
by the way i voted for Ai/shiho!seriously,create a drug like that ,at 18,she's a genius!she also can solve murders(like in vol 21...)if she want seriously,but conan is more skilled for that(same thing with yusaku,heiji...)
i think most of people in this thread are very smart but in different way and different categories!
Well fact is Yusaku is.

its hard to tell whose smarter with kaito kid and shinichi

and obviously shinichi is a lil smarter than heiji
KaitoKid0
Banned.

Posts:
216
Contact:

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by KaitoKid0 »

ayw wrote: In terms of deductions, Yuusaku;
In terms of trickery, Kid;
In science knowledge, Ai;
In gadgetry, Agasa Hakase (but he's not on the list);
In terms of resolving dangerous situations, Conan;
In terms of smartness combined with sheer coolness, Akai;
and in terms of smartness combined with fun, Heiji.
he is on the list
Xela

Posts:
287

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by Xela »

In terms of deductions, Yuusaku;
In terms of trickery, Kid;
In science knowledge, Ai;
In gadgetry, Agasa Hakase (but he's not on the list);
In terms of resolving dangerous situations, Conan;
In terms of smartness combined with sheer coolness, Akai;
and in terms of smartness combined with fun, Heiji.
Since when is "coolness" or "fun" a factor to detect the intelligence of people?
I can agree with things like "science knowledge" or "deductions", but "coolness" or "fun"
are rather describing their personalities.
(Still don´t get what´s supposed to be that fun about Heiji anyways.)
User avatar
kirite
Cookie-Eating Moderating Machine
Chillin'

Posts:
1762
Contact:

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by kirite »

I can never figure out how to answer this topic since it depends how you personally measure intelligence  :-\.

For example a person can be a genius who unravels the mysteries of the universe but can still be a complete idiot when he pisses off every single person he has ever met so in the end they'll steal his work, throw him in a bin, and send him to mars.

Or another example will be girls who are smart but acts stupid so their parents won't throw them out of the house for over shadowing their older male siblings.

...but maybe those examples are just from where I come from xD.

Wouldn't some people call a comedian someone who's absolutely brilliant?  Aren't sculptors and painters and some people who throws tomatoes at paintings called geniuses?  Aren't Historians, Poets, Mangakas, Doctors, Fat man who sit in chair and solves crimes also considered intellectuals? 

Meh most people are overatted by hype.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that intelligence is judged depending on many factors.  It really depends what you feel like measuring at the moment. 

----

And to be more on topic I think Conan/Shinichi is the smartest simply because of Main Character Hax.  Even in terms of (pratical) scientific knowledge Conan (the highschool student) is better then Haibara (the scientific genius).

1)  Conan can tell the difference between chemicals without a lab test faster then everyone, everytime.

2)  Haibara doesn't know how to deal with static electricity....that was weird.

3)  The drug Haibara make is a soft science nightmare which is the equivalent of a stone that shed tears of immortality on a full moon.  I have no idea how to gadge her scientific knowledge right now xD.  Hence why I said pratical- as in knowledge she can use in her daily I-see-corpses-everywhere life.
Hey, I have an idea, let's have a THIS SUCKS / NO THIS SUCKS / NO YOU / NO YOU argument for a couple pages, that will really be great. - Ingmar
SkyVenger
Community Hero
ᶘ ᵒᴥᵒᶅ

Posts:
877

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by SkyVenger »

The former Kid would've topped the charts, but he's dead :P
So the smartest would be his rival ^^
I wonder why he was quite stupid in acting as an old man though (anime ep though, so not canon)
User avatar
bluekaitou1412
Community Phantom
Indie artist. Likes books and all things Haibara.

Posts:
5389

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by bluekaitou1412 »

@kirite
ur definitely right!!!
ranger
Community Villain

Posts:
3588

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by ranger »

kirite wrote:
2)  Haibara doesn't know how to deal with static electricity....that was weird.

I think it was more because she was scared of it, thus not being able to deal with her fear...

If conan's dad is smarter than conan, then it's definetely yusaku in overall smarts.

But, I think Gin  can damn be up there, they seem to be tactical geniuses.  Gin can sense traps, what his enemies are planning.
Image
Image
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by Eve »

ranger wrote:
kirite wrote:
2)  Haibara doesn't know how to deal with static electricity....that was weird.

I think it was more because she was scared of it, thus not being able to deal with her fear...

If conan's dad is smarter than conan, then it's definetely yusaku in overall smarts.

But, I think Gin  can damn be up there, they seem to be tactical geniuses.  Gin can sense traps, what his enemies are planning.



I agree... she's the type who would run away from her fear ^_^... only since she have met Conan that she started to face them ^_^

Tactical genius, Science Genius, Deduction Genius, Fictional Genius, Etc, = Aoyama Gosho!XDDDD

But Yeah... considering Yusaku and...  Toichi (?) are both smarter than their sons... then okaythey are the genius here... but then the one who take down Toichi, Snake (?) wouldn't he be smarter??? Then it's all back to the BO being smarter XDDD....

p.s. (Who's luckier XD)
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
宮野志ä¿
治癒ã

Posts:
45

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by å®®é‡Žå¿—ä¿ »

Shinichi, because the Author made him the smartest one... ;)
ImageImageImage
takiko

Posts:
1107

Re: Who's the smartest?

Post by takiko »

[quote="宮野志ä¿
Locked