DC Specials Contest (Semifinals): 188-193 vs 345

[1Kaito]

Episode 345 was the most epic scene in Detective Conan. Desperate Revival Arc was..."ehh"

Don't say that. DR was one amazing arc.

There was so many things that Gosho coud have done differently that would have made it amazing but I feel not enough was shown and not enough was said to make it a good arc, but it was a great development

[Girl19]

Episode 345 was the most epic scene in Detective Conan. Desperate Revival Arc was..."ehh"

Spoiler:

LOL I do think the DR arc was great awesome, but it lacked something very important. *Hint*BO*Hint*

[PT]

Not to forget, comparing a whole arc (Desperate Revival, 188-193) with one episode (345) was kinda unfair since the beginning..

Not really since they're about as long?

It's not about being long, it's about the fact that 345 also has its own arc. The episodes right before 345 are directly related to the events of 345.
I meant we should have compared both arcs together, not a-whole-arc with only-the-last-part-of-another-arc. But it's just my opinion.

But 345 still won, so I don't see what the problem is.

[Girl19]

But 345 still won, so I don't see what the problem is.

There is no problem on my side. Even if the DR arc had won, there wouldn't be.
I was just pointing out to what seems to me an unfair comparison.

[Wakarimashita]

Episode 345 was the most epic scene in Detective Conan. Desperate Revival Arc was..."ehh"

Spoiler:

LOL I do think the DR arc was great awesome, but it lacked something very important. *Hint*BO*Hint*

I might have considered voting for 345 if there had not been the case on the ship which I didn't like and I felt dragged the episode on too much. Oh, and DR had the best (or 2nd best) AiCon interaction ever ! 

[Girl19]

I might have considered voting for 345 if there had not been the case on the ship which I didn't like and I felt dragged the episode on too much. Oh, and DR had the best (or 2nd best) AiCon interaction ever ! 

True, and as much as I love AiCon, I think BO interests me more! If the DR arc had some BO, it would definitely be my favorite arc ever! ^^

[PT]

But 345 still won, so I don't see what the problem is.

There is no problem on my side. Even if the DR arc had won, there wouldn't be.
I was just pointing out to what seems to me an unfair comparison.

Ah. Well, apparently it's not that unfair. The competition was tied the entire time, so even for it being just one episode vs. an arc, it did pretty well.

[Girl19]

But 345 still won, so I don't see what the problem is.

There is no problem on my side. Even if the DR arc had won, there wouldn't be.
I was just pointing out to what seems to me an unfair comparison.

Ah. Well, apparently it's not that unfair. The competition was tied the entire time, so even for it being just one episode vs. an arc, it did pretty well.

True. I didn't keep track of the competition during the week, but now that I read previous comments, it seems to have been breathtaking!

[PokerFace312]

345: I love everything, though some things seemed a bit pointless, and in my opinion to slow-mo they tried to do in the episode just looked stupid.
DR: Absolutely adore. I've read and watched it more times than anything else in the series and every time I see the volumes with it at the library, I can't help but check them out. The only thing is that at this part:

Spoiler:

I honest to God just want to kill Haibara for stopping Conan from telling Ran.

Just my opinion.

[pofa]

Wow, that was close. It deserved to be close, though.

[kkslider5552000]

The real winner is Detective Conan fans.