File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
Miyano-sama
ã

Posts:
114
Contact:

File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Miyano-sama »

Image
Haibara made a prototype antidote for APTX 4869, and hid it inside a drawer, with an evil intention to test it on Kudo Shinichi secretly, when he comes next time to stay at Professor Agasa's house. Since she put it inside a container for cold medicine, Profesor Agasa mistook it for a cold medicine and give it to Conan. Then guess what... Conan takes it and becomes Shinichi again!

Now that we know this, nobody can deny that Haibara is really evil!!
ã
xtuyet

Posts:
50

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by xtuyet »

ROFLLLLLL XD kyoot.

Mmm personally :] i think she isn't evil XD
Laroeng

Posts:
2

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Laroeng »

Actually I don't believe it...
if she is a devil, so why she gave many advantages to the most of conan c
User avatar
Jd-
DCTP Staff Member

Posts:
6180

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Jd- »

Evvvvilllll!
jelly_Ace

Posts:
44

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by jelly_Ace »

i wouldn't call her evil...but she is definitely unethical! talk about human medical experimentation! where are the bioethics people when you need them???

but considering that she developed drugs to kill people in the first place...
I am five evil steps ahead of you.
User avatar
tepiestar
do manly girlie men really exist?

Posts:
166

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by tepiestar »

she worked/lived with the b.o. since she was like, what, 5?  i'm don't think ethics was part of the education they gave her.  so haibara is not evil.  she is merely a prodigy cultivated by the black org.  who just happen to be evil.  hmmm.... :D haha. 

besides, if it worked (fat chance) shinichi would have been all for it.  he's all about finding a cure. 
codename64546

Posts:
147

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by codename64546 »

I think it was supposed to be a surprise not in a "evil" way  :-\
Image
User avatar
ten

Posts:
258

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by ten »

If not evil she is rather mean, especially to Shinichi (she is nice to animals though! =) ).  Remember the end in the Desperate Revival arc she sort of led Conan to believe that this antidote might work, but she really knew all along exactly how long the antidote would last -- at the end she says something like 24 minutes longer then I expected, within the expected range, which means she knew how long he had and didn't bother telling him -- haha =) MEAN!
Juansmarts

Posts:
241
Contact:

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Juansmarts »

tepiestar wrote: she worked/lived with the b.o. since she was like, what, 5?
I loled when I read that statement :D
I understaned living with the Black Org, but working for them at 5 years old?

Well, I guess that it's okay for Haibara to be mean on her only test subject, since he is willing to take it. Even if he knew it was a prototype antidote, I bet he would have taken it in an instant.
Miyano-sama
ã

Posts:
114
Contact:

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Miyano-sama »

Juansmarts wrote:
Well, I guess that it's okay for Haibara to be mean on her only test subject, since he is willing to take it. Even if he knew it was a prototype antidote, I bet he would have taken it in an instant.
I think Haibara had more in her mind than that. I'm guessing that she planned to put Conan in a cage and watch what happens to him when he takes the antidote. After all she is that kind of mad scientist.
8) 8) 8)
ã
User avatar
Tenken

Posts:
322
Contact:

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Tenken »

If she doesn't test it on Conan, whom else would be ideal ?
It doesn't look like she's happy about it, though
AnonX

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by AnonX »

Here's a vid I found:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKw2EcqELP4

I did not make this AMV.

*returns to the shadows*

X
EdogawaConanTantei
"Holmes of the Heisei Era"

Posts:
219

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by EdogawaConanTantei »

Miyano-sama wrote:
Image
Haibara made a prototype antidote for APTX 4869, and hid it inside a drawer, with an evil intention to test it on Kudo Shinichi secretly, when he comes next time to stay at Professor Agasa's house. Since she put it inside a container for cold medicine, Profesor Agasa mistook it for a cold medicine and give it to Conan. Then guess what... Conan takes it and becomes Shinichi again!

Now that we know this, nobody can deny that Haibara is really evil!!

This entire post makes no sense. You have the intuition of a journalist on his first day at-the-job. As a Haibara fan, I'm insulted.
Image
User avatar
Tsurugi
キザな悪党

Posts:
56

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by Tsurugi »

EdogawaConanTantei wrote: This entire post makes no sense. You have the intuition of a journalist on his first day at-the-job. As a Haibara fan, I'm insulted.
Can't recognize a joke when you see one?
User avatar
ten

Posts:
258

Re: File 646: Haibara is Evil !!

Post by ten »

to be fair to haibara as a scientist (though she really is not by my standards), she wouldn't tell conan about the secret testing because of the placebo effect -- she wants to see how long the cure lasts, if she tells him this is her new prototype it might affect how long the cure lasts (especially since he has the idea already that her cures have been so far only temporary)

though I do think she has some ulterior motive so she might be evil -- I don't buy her original story that she never memorized her work on aptx, that sounds like total bs -- if you spent years developing a drug you damn well would be able to remember it and how to recreate it
Last edited by ten on April 12th, 2008, 11:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply