New case (741-742)

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.

It's Chiba's turn now. Who is his first love? (the girl in the file)

Yumi
10
23%
Akemi
0
No votes
Okiya
4
9%
Chianti
1
2%
The boss
2
5%
Why the **** should we even care?
22
50%
......
4
9%
Kobayashi
0
No votes
Satou
0
No votes
Azusa Enomoto
0
No votes
Yui Uehara
0
No votes
Yoko Okino
1
2%
Phantom lady
0
No votes
 
Total votes: 44
User avatar
Jd-
DCTP Staff Member

Posts:
6180

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Jd- »

I think there's a very legitimate complaint here; it isn't like people asking, "Why no kiss for Ran & Shinichi!?!?!1/1/". This is yet another instance of Gosho trying to pull the same old sentimentalist strings, despite having done this with practically every single couple in the series so far. When you run something into the ground like this, it no longer has any effect. Like, the Shiratori case was already tired, and now this? Unless Chiba's first love turns out to be Megure, I can't imagine I will look on the resolution to this case favorably. If the Shiratori version of this story (which is almost always practically the same, and his was no doubt the least plausible and the worst) had come earlier in the series, we'd have likely liked it more and it may have had the intended effect. Instead--for me at least--it was like, "Not this again..."

Well, at least we all have to suffer through it together.
Spoiler:
Again.
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Eve »

Jd- wrote: I think there's a very legitimate complaint here; it isn't like people asking, "Why no kiss for Ran & Shinichi!?!?!1/1/". This is yet another instance of Gosho trying to pull the same old sentimentalist strings, despite having done this with practically every single couple in the series so far. When you run something into the ground like this, it no longer has any effect. Like, the Shiratori case was already tired, and now this? Unless Chiba's first love turns out to be Megure, I can't imagine I will look on the resolution to this case favorably. If the Shiratori version of this story (which is almost always practically the same, and his was no doubt the least plausible and the worst) had come earlier in the series, we'd have likely liked it more and it may have had the intended effect. Instead--for me at least--it was like, "Not this again..."

Well, at least we all have to suffer through it together.
Spoiler:
Again.
In my mind, I'm hoping this will be the last since I have no other sideline characters in mind for the next Oh-God-Tokyo-Is-So-Small-I'm-Bumping-Into-Long-Lost-Childhood-Crushes-Everywhere File, so I guess I'll stick around through this one... after I'm done with the stress reduction kit
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Nyarl »

Khinkhun wrote:
Kor wrote: REJOICE PEOPLE! It's the case which everyone was waiting for! Finally, the favorite character of everyone will ALSO be coupled with someone in the same wonderful, and very refreshing, concept of "childhood friends" which everyone likes so much! I mean, it's Chiba! Everyone was always wondering who his romantic interest is.

Ok, enough sarcasm. I'm not surprised. Na'a, not even slightly. When there was first Shiratori's love case, I said "Soon we'll have Chiba's first love". I mean, it's Gosho. It was obvious he wouldn't let ANYONE stay alone at the end. Let's hope Chiba's love is Yumi, so we won't need to see HER romance later on.


Don't open the spoiler if you don't want to see my rantings....
Spoiler:
IT'S FREAKING CHIBA!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHY DOES GOSHO THINK WE EVEN CARE????????? AAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHH
(don't take what I write so seriously btw. Gosho can't really make me angry since he's too predictable now)
Chiba, Chiba, the next one will be..... will Gosho running out of first love? or am I missing a character?

BTW, Yumi is engaged isn't she? I don't remember her marital status... hmm it's been so long since I've seen her...
Yumi mentions an ex-boyfriend in Secret Path to School. She even describes him a bit... so I wouldn't be surprised at all if we are eventually shown him. Aoyama probably had Shiratori/Kobayashi planned back then, too, since a few cases after that we get Ayumi thinking that Kobayashi without the glasses looks like Sato. (In hindsight, Aoyama was also pretty clearly fresh off his immunology research for Eisuke's leukemia and blood type change, since both of those cases involved allergies, and a case in between introduced Eisuke. I think I even joked somewhere about the anime stringing them together with some fillers so they could just keep reusing allergies for Next Conan's Hint.)
Khinkhun wrote:
Jd- wrote: I think there's a very legitimate complaint here; it isn't like people asking, "Why no kiss for Ran & Shinichi!?!?!1/1/". This is yet another instance of Gosho trying to pull the same old sentimentalist strings, despite having done this with practically every single couple in the series so far. When you run something into the ground like this, it no longer has any effect. Like, the Shiratori case was already tired, and now this? Unless Chiba's first love turns out to be Megure, I can't imagine I will look on the resolution to this case favorably. If the Shiratori version of this story (which is almost always practically the same, and his was no doubt the least plausible and the worst) had come earlier in the series, we'd have likely liked it more and it may have had the intended effect. Instead--for me at least--it was like, "Not this again..."

Well, at least we all have to suffer through it together.
Spoiler:
Again.
In my mind, I'm hoping this will be the last since I have no other sideline characters in mind for the next Oh-God-Tokyo-Is-So-Small-I'm-Bumping-Into-Long-Lost-Childhood-Crushes-Everywhere File, so I guess I'll stick around through this one... after I'm done with the stress reduction kit
Nyarl: Right, because all the childhood friend pairs are so much more functional couples than the pairs like Sonoko-Makoto and Takagi-Sato.
Nyarl: Yukiko-Yusaku, too...
Nyarl: Shiratori-Kobayashi is also exactly the same as Kazuha-Heiji because a first love from a brief encounter is the same as a first love of long time freinds because they are all children.
Nyarl: {were all children when the met}
Nyarl: Aoyama's just telling the same story always with different pairs. No creativity at all. [/sarcasm] More convenient abstraction from the jaded "fans" trying to justify their jadedness...
Last edited by Nyarl on July 14th, 2010, 3:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
é»’ã
User avatar
kkslider5552000
Community Villain
Enjoys making videos that no one will watch

Posts:
8032
Contact:

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by kkslider5552000 »

Nyarl's just asking to be raped by Jd.
Let's Play Bioshock Infinite: https://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?f= ... 94#p879594

Image

3DS friend code: 2878 - 9709 - 5054
Wii U ID: SliderGamer55
CarpetCrawler
Community Hero

Posts:
469

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by CarpetCrawler »

I actually really like Chiba, and think he is awesome with his over-the-top stupidity that he displays sometimes, as well as his laziness (I get a kick out of the "Chiba is fat" jokes, then again it helps that he's the character that I resemble the most :o), so chalk me up as one of the few guys that will like this. Though it seems the obvious choice is Yumi. I mean, shit, those two are the only single officers left, right?

However, I really have to agree with the overwhelming majority in that Gosho is really, really reaching when it comes to this stuff. But, I guess that's what happens when you're at 700+ chapters of a manga with no signs of stopping anytime soon.
Jd- wrote: Unless Chiba's first love turns out to be Megure, I can't imagine I will look on the resolution to this case favorably.
Spoiler:
Image

You've just been kicked out of the Megasa Fan Club, asshole.
Last edited by CarpetCrawler on July 14th, 2010, 3:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
pofa
Community Savior
Armchair sorcerey

Posts:
1183

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by pofa »

Aww, do we have to? Chiba's good as a bachelor. I'll miss seeing him and his crazy criminal roommates. :P Maybe it will be a good mystery, at least.

Although I will laugh if his first love is an otaku like him (especially if that otaku is Yumi). Or maybe it's Yoko Okino. :o
ImageImageImage

Superman = Captain America > Aquaman = Hal Jordan > Wonder Woman > Barry Allen > Thor > Martian Manhunter > The Hulk > Wasp > Hawkeye > [power gap] > Iron Man = Batman > [power gap] > Hank Pym
Akemi~chan
self-proclaimed Community Ghost

Posts:
1208
Contact:

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Akemi~chan »

she had baggy hair,theres a possability of it being yumi, most likely not. her attitude is peculiar too. hmmm..either she's someone introduced as a small character once or she has yet to come into the series...or she's sato-san. (i saw a resemblance)
Image
User avatar
Commi-Ninja

Posts:
1583

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Commi-Ninja »

It would be awful if it were Sato.  I mean, isn't practically the entire police department in love with her already?
3DS FC: 4699-5851-2068
I might wake up early and go running. I also might wake up and win the lottery. The odds are about the same.
User avatar
GinRei
DCTP Staff Member
銀霊

Posts:
3388
Contact:

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by GinRei »

Since I already believe Chiba to be the head of the BO, his childhood crush will turn out to be Kir or Chianti.  This will thus lead into the next BO case.
kentasaiba
Mr. Pickles!

Posts:
584

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by kentasaiba »

No one Chiba X Takagi?
Image
User avatar
Jd-
DCTP Staff Member

Posts:
6180

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Jd- »

pofa wrote: Aww, do we have to? Chiba's good as a bachelor. I'll miss seeing him and his crazy criminal roommates. :P Maybe it will be a good mystery, at least.

Although I will laugh if his first love is an otaku like him (especially if that otaku is Yumi). Or maybe it's Yoko Okino. :o
One thing that Gosho is always prepared to unintentionally hammer in is that many of his characters really are as one-dimensional as they appear, like Chiba. Chiba's purpose has always been very clear cut and he isn't even bad in that role. However, when Gosho gives him a childhood love and tries to make something out of nothing (again), it's made terribly obvious that the character is even more insignificant than we thought. If Gosho feels it necessary to utilize his favorite plot device outside of implausible disguises (childhood loves) for this character, we can only conclude that he really isn't outstanding in the least.
GinRei wrote: Since I already believe Chiba to be the head of the BO, his childhood crush will turn out to be Kir or Chianti.  This will thus lead into the next BO case.
Fact. :-X
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Eve »

GinRei wrote: Since I already believe Chiba to be the head of the BO, his childhood crush will turn out to be Kir or Chianti.  This will thus lead into the next BO case.
WOW, I didn't think of that connection at all :O Genius!
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Nyarl »

Jd- wrote: One thing that Gosho is always prepared to unintentionally hammer in is that many of his characters really are as one-dimensional as they appear, like Chiba. Chiba's purpose has always been very clear cut and he isn't even bad in that role. However, when Gosho gives him a childhood love and tries to make something out of nothing (again), it's made terribly obvious that the character is even more insignificant than we thought. If Gosho feels it necessary to utilize his favorite plot device outside of implausible disguises (childhood loves) for this character, we can only conclude that he really isn't outstanding in the least.
How is that a logical criticism at all? "If Gosho feels it necessary to utilize his favorite plot device (implausible disguises), then we can only conclude the Org. plot isn't outstanding in the least," makes exactly as much sense, but both are ultimately empty assertion. "I don't like it," is a much more meaningful and honest way of putting it, if less pretentious (though, still possibly retarded before the story is out in any readable form).
é»’ã
Blaze of Glory

Posts:
40

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Blaze of Glory »

Jesus Christ make him stop! For the love of god make him stop!

I am so sick of all this lovey dovey crap!
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: New case (741-???)

Post by Nyarl »

Blaze of Glory wrote: Jesus Christ make him stop! For the love of god make him stop!

I am so sick of all this lovey dovey crap!
Aoyama wrote: 5. What was the driving force behind your decision to draw Detective Conan?
I wanted to write/draw a romantic comedy whose main character was a detective that has been made small again.
You picked the wrong manga if you don't want that lovey dovy crap. Aoyama knows the mysteries are the main draw, but he's gonna go back to the premise until it makes you sick.
é»’ã
Locked