What would YOU do?

If you have some randomness to share that you can't post elsewhere, this is the place to do it.

Would you take the money?

Yes
8
36%
No
14
64%
 
Total votes: 22
meidei
ã

Posts:
185
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by meidei »

You don't tamper with the evidence. Period.
Image
冷コーã
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Abs. »

Obviously when this acquaintance collapses, you do the normal things like curse, check for a pulse, call for an ambulance, etc...  But there's no pulse, no breathing, zero signs of life at all.  The ambulance people have told you it'll be about 15-30 minutes before they get there.  You're sitting there with a dead body.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
sstimson
Everyone a Critic

Posts:
2588
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by sstimson »

http://organizedwisdom.com/Cold_Treatment_for_Heart_Attack_Patients

Though he might be dead. If you act fact enough you might be able to save their life.
That being the case getting to body to a very cold spot could save their life. Therefore move the body to a freezer or find ice to pack the body with. Doing nothing means the body is certain dead.  A new question is if you knew you could save a life by cold treatment would you?
Later

Invisible Member
Spoiler: SS Present from PT
Image
Akonyl
Community Hero

Posts:
4200

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Akonyl »

Lots of you seem to be missing the point. :P

The topic isn't about "would you save your friend" or "how would you save your friend" or "how can you tell that your friend is dead"

It's not a question if you can tell if your friend is alive or not. The premise of the topic is that your friend died, and that is a fact. Given that fact, how would you respond to the money situation?

That's sort of like being asked "if you ordered a plain hamburger at a restaurant, what would you put on it", and saying "well how do I know it's not actually a chicken sandwich? Because I'd put pickles on my chicken sandwich."
sstimson
Everyone a Critic

Posts:
2588
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by sstimson »

Akonyl wrote: Lots of you seem to be missing the point. :P

The topic isn't about "would you save your friend" or "how would you save your friend" or "how can you tell that your friend is dead"

It's not a question if you can tell if your friend is alive or not. The premise of the topic is that your friend died, and that is a fact. Given that fact, how would you respond to the money situation?

That's sort of like being asked "if you ordered a plain hamburger at a restaurant, what would you put on it", and saying "well how do I know it's not actually a chicken sandwich? Because I'd put pickles on my chicken sandwich."
And I am answering that question.Even if the friend is dead. Doing nothing is out of the question. Dead People do get saved and live after the near death experience. Even if there is a one chance in 100,000,000 have would you feel if you just called the 911 and watches Precious time past that might have saved him?

AS for part two unless you bring other kinds of food to such a restaurant, then you eat or remove what they put on it. You did say PLAIN.
Later

Invisible Member
Spoiler: SS Present from PT
Image
Akonyl
Community Hero

Posts:
4200

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Akonyl »

sstimson wrote:
Akonyl wrote: Lots of you seem to be missing the point. :P

The topic isn't about "would you save your friend" or "how would you save your friend" or "how can you tell that your friend is dead"

It's not a question if you can tell if your friend is alive or not. The premise of the topic is that your friend died, and that is a fact. Given that fact, how would you respond to the money situation?

That's sort of like being asked "if you ordered a plain hamburger at a restaurant, what would you put on it", and saying "well how do I know it's not actually a chicken sandwich? Because I'd put pickles on my chicken sandwich."
And I am answering that question.Even if the friend is dead. Doing nothing is out of the question. Dead People do get saved and live after the near death experience. Even if there is a one chance in 100,000,000 have would you feel if you just called the 911 and watches Precious time past that might have saved him?

AS for part two unless you bring other kinds of food to such a restaurant, then you eat or remove what they put on it. You did say PLAIN.
you're still attempting to circumvent the question through a means which was quite obviously not the question's intent.
sstimson
Everyone a Critic

Posts:
2588
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by sstimson »

Ending this:

If I have no money and saw a store that would sale Ice when I would use their money to try and save their life.

If I have money and saw a store that sold ice, Then I would not need their money to save their life.

So GM, do I have enough money on me and is there a store that sales ice?
Later

Invisible Member
Spoiler: SS Present from PT
Image
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Abs. »

The person is dead.  There are no stores nor any people in the near vicinity.  Your cell phone died after you made the call to emergency services.  Your acquaintance did not carry a cell phone or any other communications device.  You also did not carry any other communications device.  Your vehicle is parked a convenient 5 miles away.  You do not have on your person a syringe with which someone could conjecture that you used to introduce an air bubble into the victim's bloodstream.  Your acquaintance weighs nearly three times as much as you do.  There is nothing nearby with which you could fashion any sort of rig with which to transport said acquaintance.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
meidei
ã

Posts:
185
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by meidei »

Abs. wrote: The person is dead.  There are no stores nor any people in the near vicinity.  Your cell phone died after you made the call to emergency services.  Your acquaintance did not carry a cell phone or any other communications device.  You also did not carry any other communications device.  Your vehicle is parked a convenient 5 miles away.  You do not have on your person a syringe with which someone could conjecture that you used to introduce an air bubble into the victim's bloodstream.  Your acquaintance weighs nearly three times as much as you do.  There is nothing nearby with which you could fashion any sort of rig with which to transport said acquaintance.
That's so TV-like to happen in real life.
Image
冷コーã
Kor
Administrator

Posts:
3051

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Kor »

Abs. wrote: The person is dead.  There are no stores nor any people in the near vicinity.  Your cell phone died after you made the call to emergency services.  Your acquaintance did not carry a cell phone or any other communications device.  You also did not carry any other communications device.  Your vehicle is parked a convenient 5 miles away.  You do not have on your person a syringe with which someone could conjecture that you used to introduce an air bubble into the victim's bloodstream.  Your acquaintance weighs nearly three times as much as you do.  There is nothing nearby with which you could fashion any sort of rig with which to transport said acquaintance.
Do I have super-powers that allow me to freeze the body? Do I have magical powers or maybe a scroll of "resurrection" so I can get that person back to life? Is Superman around? Do I have a time-machine so I can get back in time and warn that person before he has a heart-attack?
You have to clarify what are the settings and what are my opions/abilities, you know. (btw, I'm just kidding  ;D)
Image
sstimson
Everyone a Critic

Posts:
2588
Contact:

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by sstimson »

is it a busy street? Could I flag someone down to help? How did I get here if I parked five miles away. If I walked, did a pass a store or anything?

Gm please answer
Later

Invisible Member
Spoiler: SS Present from PT
Image
takiko

Posts:
1107

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by takiko »

meidei wrote: You don't tamper with the evidence. Period.
^This. But I loaned my acquaintance. It's mine. :(
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Abs. wrote: The person is dead.  There are no stores nor any people in the near vicinity.  Your cell phone died after you made the call to emergency services.  Your acquaintance did not carry a cell phone or any other communications device.  You also did not carry any other communications device.  Your vehicle is parked a convenient 5 miles away.  You do not have on your person a syringe with which someone could conjecture that you used to introduce an air bubble into the victim's bloodstream.  Your acquaintance weighs nearly three times as much as you do.  There is nothing nearby with which you could fashion any sort of rig with which to transport said acquaintance.
Why do I walk around the desert with my fat acquaintance who I lend money to?
Jk ;p

But actually, I always carry a syringe with me D:


Anyway, I answered to your question with a given setting. And I thought about the setting and said that I would be to busy saving the dude and wouldn't think about the money. And then it would be too late to get the money from him.
Another point, if that dude is owing me money, why would he have 100$ with him and not giving it back to me? Even if he died, he probably wouldn't carry so much money with him. Well, you could have lend it to him and he dies right after that (lol)

Anyway, I know what your point is. So still:

1) The person suddenly has a heart attack next to me. I would be too busy trying to save him and would not think about it at the moment. SO I'll call ambulance/help etc. and it would be too late to take the money back without anyone noticing.
Of course, I could go to his corpse at night and steal it. But I wouldn't do that.
-> vote: no

2) I walked around with my acquaintance and leave him on a bench to get something (in a store etc.) I leave him alone for 15 mins or more. After I came back I notice he died of a heart attack, so rescuing is impossible.
Now, if I lend him some money on a different day, I would think he doesn't have so much money with him anyway. And "looking through" a dead body and looking into his wallet is too risky considering he doesn't have the money with him.
In case I gave him the money on the same day (like 1-2hours ago) I'd get the money back from him. (trying not to look like a robber)
-> vote: no and maybe yes

3) I visit my acquaintance at his home and notice he died on the couch.
a) he was obviously murdered and I don't touch anything at all but call the police. Especially when there is a group of kids claiming to be the detective boys
b) He died a normal way. But since I watched too much DC and would be at shock, I probably wouldn't think about the money again and wouldn't try anything. Just call police.
-> vote: no

So since the risky situations are would be yes votes, and the others are no, I'd vote for no. But it really depends on the situation and if you have a clear head to think about the money.
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
Holmes
Erabareshi Kodomotachi

Posts:
1291

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by Holmes »

Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Abs. wrote: The person just up and dies.  There is no rescue.  You were walking in a place where there are few passers-by.
Well, if it's a heart attack, he doesn't just "die instantly".
And on the other hand, even if he's "pretty much dead", then you still have the duty to help and call an ambulance. Otherwise it's a crime (at least here).
IF the Death Note does not exist.  :P
My drawings thread :) Holmes´Drawings

Image
*Amazing banner done by KaitoGirl, thank you very much! :D*
ranger
Community Villain

Posts:
3588

Re: What would YOU do?

Post by ranger »

Holmes wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Abs. wrote: The person just up and dies.  There is no rescue.  You were walking in a place where there are few passers-by.
Well, if it's a heart attack, he doesn't just "die instantly".
And on the other hand, even if he's "pretty much dead", then you still have the duty to help and call an ambulance. Otherwise it's a crime (at least here).
IF the Death Note does not exist.  :P
The Bible!
Image
Image
Post Reply