DCTP Forums

Hmmm, correct me if I'm wrong, but when Haibara first suggested that Subaru may be BO, Conan's response was something along the lines of, "He couldn't be, he's a Sherlockian!" Though didn't we have a Sherlock Holmes fan case awhile back where a Sherlockian ended up being the murderer, and Conan carried on with his deduction without regarding it? Conan, you hypocrite.


I'm not a DC historian and I don't keep track of all the chapters/posts here, so my apologies if this has already been said.  But please, let's discuss plot holes! What other totally nonsensical mishaps have been circulating through DC?

Yes, that did happen, but it's (most likely) not a plot hole. Conan was using a weak argument, which he himself knows makes no sense, in order to hide a deeper, more logical reason for giving shelter to Okiya.

If Haibara had been present during the Holmes Freak Murder case, I suppose she could have brought it up as an obvious counterargument, but since she wasn't -- and probably more important, because it's just a shockingly silly statement -- she decided not to argue the point.

^What Knightus said, it was definitely NOT a plot hole.