DCTP Forums

Whaaaaaaaat?
http://forums.mangafox.com/showthread.php?t=140362

Haha, yeah.

At first I thought that sstimson's were far-fetched, but that DX guy has reached a whole new level.

Well, that was weird...

Kor wrote: At first I thought that sstimson's were far-fetched, but that DX guy has reached a whole new level.

Hahahahahaha!

I knew I was in for a threat when he spelled "threat" as "treat" in the title.
(my typo intended)

And Andre Camel is Shiho's mother... brilliant!

Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a sixth sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a six sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

sstimson wrote:

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a six sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

I think I'll point out why this theory is incorrect far quicker than Chekhov could ever do.

THAT. WOULD. BE. STUPID. HORRIBLE. AWFUL. ETC.

the end

I dunno what you guys are about. DetectiveConanDX's theories are completely fine and reasonable. They are based on facts and are thus, brilliant.

On the other hand, Chekhov's theories are completely  false and stupid. No one can expect to believe Chekhov after all these fail theories...


[/sarcasm]

kkslider5552000 wrote:

sstimson wrote:

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a six sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

I think I'll point out why this theory is incorrect far quicker than Chekhov could ever do.

THAT. WOULD. BE. STUPID. HORRIBLE. AWFUL. ETC.

the end

The above is examples of:

From Logical Fallasies

False Premise:
All of the other fallacies are decent, but clearly not the best as they didn't come from kkslider5552000 incredibly large and sexy brain.

Ad Hominem:
This is the best logical fallacy, and if you disagree with me, well, sstimson suck.

no, I'm not falling for this. I called your opinion stupid, you insulted me. Amusing.  :-*

You should be more blatant when calling me an elitist asshole though. If my jokes are any indication, not everyone here is that great with subtlety.

kkslider5552000 wrote: no, I'm not falling for this. I called your opinion stupid, you insulted me. Amusing.  :-*

You should be more blatant when calling me an elitist asshole though. If my jokes are any indication, not everyone here is that great with subtlety.

Fixed is the below more correct?

sstimson wrote:

kkslider5552000 wrote:

sstimson wrote:

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a six sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

I think I'll point out why this theory is incorrect far quicker than Chekhov could ever do.

THAT. WOULD. BE. STUPID. HORRIBLE. AWFUL. ETC.

the end

The above is examples of:

From Logical Fallasies

False Premise:
All of the other statements are decent, but clearly not the best as they didn't come from kkslider5552000 incredibly large and sexy brain.

Ad Hominem:
This is the best statement, and if you disagree with me, well, sstimson suck.

sstimson wrote:

kkslider5552000 wrote: no, I'm not falling for this. I called your opinion stupid, you insulted me. Amusing. 

You should be more blatant when calling me an elitist asshole though. If my jokes are any indication, not everyone here is that great with subtlety.

Fixed is the below more correct?

sstimson wrote:

kkslider5552000 wrote:

sstimson wrote:

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: Funny, you bring this up. I had a chat with Abs. about it a few months ago or so. I don't think it is a troll theory because too much effort was put into it and he posted another one later about Detective Conan being ... one massive rickroll!
Andre Camel being Shiho's Mom was definitely the highlight, but other bits I found amusing were: Three separate Akais (triplets?), Okiya is Haibara's father, James Black is the leader of the Black Organization, Agasa is Haibara's granddad on her father's side and can make holograms, numerology, the movies and the names of the English dub are canon, there is a separate "Red Organization" made up of assorted protagonists, the Black Organization and the aforementioned "Red Org." members have special genes that confer a six sense on people, and Shinichi will be "infected by darkness".
This theory was actually stranger earlier than it is now! DetectiveConanDX used to have a theory about using numerology to predict the end of the series... which was manga chap 736 or 763 if I remember correctly. After it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, he edited his posts to remove the reference to that theory as an oops moment. The strangest part was he was predicting that Shinichi and Kaito Kid were literally going to merge like in DBZ to purge his inner darkness and make some super thief detective, but DetectiveConanDX has since edited his posts to remove this reference as well. I wonder why?

I am a bit worried sstimson's questionable theory is heading in this direction although this one takes the cake by an order or two of magnitude.


Is anyone else tempted to submit DX's theories to the theory reference sticky thread?

Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

I think I'll point out why this theory is incorrect far quicker than Chekhov could ever do.

THAT. WOULD. BE. STUPID. HORRIBLE. AWFUL. ETC.

the end

The above is examples of:

From Logical Fallasies

False Premise:
All of the other statements are decent, but clearly not the best as they didn't come from kkslider5552000 incredibly large and sexy brain.

Ad Hominem:
This is the best statement, and if you disagree with me, well, sstimson suck.

...um...I was honestly expecting continued subtlety but...OK. Thanks? That...um...was quick...


...huh.

sstimson wrote: Since you mentioned me. My theory leads to the following 1) the BO know Conan is not dead. 2) Gin is lying about not remembering names.
3) most of the BO cases have been test for Conan. 4) Hairaba needed to find out why the Drug reversed.

Yeah, but your theory has major problems. There is no evidence to support this theory that the much simpler theory that the org doesn't know about Conan can't already explain adequately. It creates more contradictions than it supposedly resolves, and your explanations of some of those contradictions means that the entire logical premise of the story is undermined as well as the principles of good storytelling, characterization, etc.