The Scar Akai inconsistency could've been a hint that it wasn't a real scar or have to do with the way the light hit it. Other than that, Gosho is human. None of us are perfect.Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:I think you are making a mountain out of a molehill. You seem to be treating these "rules" about proportion as if they were divinely ordained so Gosho must be following them. I said we should prove that's true before making assumptions by examining the art in a methodical and deliberate fashion. It's not something that difficult to do. All you have to do is pick a sample of sample of pictures and see which ones conform to the norms and which ones are exceptions.Yuki_JX wrote:k11chi wrote:Well you can be sure Gosho never even touched those manga tutorial books you are talking about... This is 20 years old series.
I wonder how many mangaka actually care... Even if they do, seeing as how it has that weekly schedule and not even monthly manga do better anyway...
Do you knew Gosho personally?? if not, how you can be so sure Gosho never even touched those manga tutorial in his whole life?? Mangaka needs a references to begin with it may vary from encyclopedia to a manga tutorial book. A beginner who wants to be a mangaka will pick manga tutorial as reference obviously. For veteran mangaka they learn their stuffs most by experiences, but there is no law stated that a veteran mangaka must not use/read/TOUCH a manga tutorial book, right? Manga Tutorial may serve as guide, a reminder, reference for all mangaka
Some Mangaka don't actually care and these carelessness is resulting/creating inconsistency in their work. But there also inconsistency created because of time pressure and poor research.
Most fans already knew about Dragon Ball and Bleach inconsistencies, which is both far to the genre of Conan which is mystery who needs more consistency than the fantasy genre. And also I only mentioning/discussing the ratio & proportion of human body and how it can affect to the sex and age of the character FYI.
Second Gosho has been noted to have some inconsistencies. He isn't perfect all the time.
Scar Akai's scar changed from panel to panel in the same case.Shinichi's bathroom door likes to reverse itself.Spoiler: Scar Collage
Spoiler: 812 handle on the right in the insideAnd Sonoko's shirt can jump through her arms.Spoiler: 812 handle switches to the leftSpoiler:
Yuki, you need to take a step back and calm down. Nobody here may know Gosho personally and he may have a generally consistent art style, but there is always a possibility that Mask Subaru's proportions ended up wonky or are a red herring and that it's Akai in the disguise instead of someone else.
)and also considering the possibility of its only someone's dream(to farfetched? I know). But we must also consider the fact that this is a part of a big main series (a huge revelation may come) so having a huge inconsistency in here is unforgivable.
