*SPOILER FREE* Discussion Thread: Detective Conan Files 818-

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Posted this at DCW, but something strikes me as odd with Conan's deduction. If the guy really put string up in the hall to open his own door, wouldn't the wheelchair from D had run into it since Andou would have placed it when he went to room B around the time of the phone call? Also Conan failed to mention who was the running person. There might be something else going on here with Conan's deduction that Conan hasn't mentioned, especially since last chapter's questioning he grilled the old lady, but hadn't revealed the reason why.

I wonder if Ran is thinking that someone wrote the message for Haibara because she used her whole name? Also Conan giving Amuro the look when he appeared probably means Conan knows Amuro's identity now. Amuro also seems to know quite a bit about the case for not being around; is it bugs or second hand knowledge?

I think the canister under the seat might be sleeping gas or tear gas rather than a bomb. The first would let the BO investigate the train, the second would flush Sherry out onto the platform.

I still don't know why Vermouth threw Yukiko's luggage out of the train. Does she think Yukiko had something troublesome in there?

[Akonyl]

is it just me or is the way the chain lock's set up weird? Whenever I've seen chain locks, the slider is on the door itself and the chain's anchor is on the wall (so that you can't easily see what you're doing if you try to unlock it and it's harder to manipulate), not the other way around.

I still don't know why Vermouth threw Yukiko's luggage out of the train. Does she think Yukiko had something troublesome in there?

I figure that if it's Yukiko, her main strength is being able to disguise herself/others, and there might have been supplies for it inside her suitcase. So by getting rid of it, she lowers the probability of Yukiko doing something like disguising Ai/Shiho, or something.

[Commi-Ninja]

Am I the only one ridiculously excited about a Yukiko/Vermouth showdown?

Also, I probably read it wrong, but I thought I saw that the rope tying the doors together went through the window rather than outside in the hallway.

[unclesporkums]

Am I the only one ridiculously excited about a Yukiko/Vermouth showdown?

Nope! I am too!

[hiten22]

Am I the only one ridiculously excited about a Yukiko/Vermouth showdown?

Nope! I am too!

I'm ON for that :]..

[Kogorou]

It was bound to happen at some time and maybe finally Gosho will give us a great showdown
Yukiko vs Sharon ~ I can't wait

Did I miss something:
What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

[Akonyl]

What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

absolutely nothing, sometimes Vermy just wants to be a complete jerk. :V

[Kogorou]

What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

absolutely nothing, sometimes Vermy just wants to be a complete jerk. :V

I figured that but there must be some meaning to it
Well Yukiko said something about that "One Piece" ~ maybe a dress XD

[yamiangie]

What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

absolutely nothing, sometimes Vermy just wants to be a complete jerk. :V

I figured that but there must be some meaning to it
Well Yukiko said something about that "One Piece" ~ maybe a dress XD

Since it's "One Piece" it's a treasured item.  Unless you think Gol D. Roger hid a dress somewhere Raftel.

[Borealis]

Came back form Scotland yesterday/today.... Read all the chapters.... WHUT?!

Going to read this tread now.
Where does Vermouth keep her hair? Under the hat?

And Okiya seems to be on the good side

[Dus]

What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

absolutely nothing, sometimes Vermy just wants to be a complete jerk. :V

So that's why Yukiko said "Isn't it about time you stopped doing this sort of thing?"? Because Vermouth is always bullying her and such a big meanie?

[Stopwatch]

its strange that the FBI still didn't make an appearance.

Why would they be involved?

[Incomplete-tantei]

What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

absolutely nothing, sometimes Vermy just wants to be a complete jerk. :V

So that's why Yukiko said "Isn't it about time you stopped doing this sort of thing?"? Because Vermouth is always bullying her and such a big meanie?

I think Yukiko said that because Vermouth is still disguising and trying to trick people.
Humm so Yukiko ends up to be the Mystery Woman huh.. well can't help it, but Gosho has to make it hype then!

its strange that the FBI still didn't make an appearance.

You mean in the train? Personally I don't think they'll show up in the train..

And Conan's reaction to Amuro.. finally he has realized Amuro is a bad guy? And I wonder where did Vermouth put Sera xD
If Okiya finds out Sera unconscious... he's gonna commit murder on Vermouth/Bourbon!
And thus will begin the second crime on the Orient Express Bell Tree Express!

I also think Ran suspects the mail and doesn't think Haibara wrote it. I wonder if Haibara took the antidote yet ? As for Agasa, looks like he was told by Conan the Org was on the train, at page 13.

PS : @Chekhov : Since Andou ends up to be the murderer, is Komino Natsue or Sumitomo Hiroka the accomplice? I didn't read your solution though...

[GinRei]

Did I miss something:
What was is that luggage Sharon threw out of the train?

Based on what Yukiko said, it appears to have been her luggage.  Therefore, Vermouth was likely trying to remove any way to disguise Shiho.

[unclesporkums]

Based on what Yukiko said, it appears to have been her luggage.  Therefore, Vermouth was likely trying to remove any way to disguise Shiho.

^ This makes sense to me.