File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
Nyarl
Lost Detective

Posts:
670

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Nyarl »

I don't think it's surprise Akai is alive, even if he deduced Akai had been killed I'd think he'd be happy at the possibility he had been wrong, rather than horrified. Much more likely he and Akai miscalculated when they thought the Org. would concentrate on finding Shiho rather than do something that basically declares war on the FBI by sending out the fake. Either that or he realizes it's possible the plan to fake Akai's death didn't go smoothly and Okiya isn't who he initially thought. (A Mission:Impossible plan that blows up in the protagonists' faces (and in a way they didn't really to intend to happen) would be a good twist. Conan actually believing that Holmes fan nonsense wouldn't.)
é»’ã
User avatar
Sere

Posts:
416

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Sere »

In literature and fiction, the author can do a lot of things. Like, reviving the death and misleading the reader. But I myself think, that it's only good to revive a character, when there is a plausible reason. In my view, the reason for Akais death is much more important, than for him being still alive. Cause his death would prove the importance of Kir and, that the BO is able to carry out there plans all along, what makes them even more dangerous. I read all the guesses here, but I still can't believe them, cause i just can't see a reason for it all. Well, if Akai is alive, i will be slighty disappointed cause sometimes, a dead charakter is much more interesting than a revived one. But well, maybe I think about it a bit too scientific... should go back to my studies...
Hitomi

Posts:
7

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Hitomi »

Just imagine that Akai is really dead, and the one who'll return with akai's apparence is bourbon. Lol it's stupid, but that's still a theory  :P
Natsumi
(:

Posts:
23

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Natsumi »

Tenken wrote: My interpretation:

- Akai is supposed to play dead. Why does he appear in public? Or

- Okiya is Akai. So who the heck is that other Akai?

Waiting for some big surprise ;D
You have it all wrong. I was lruking, but i decided to make an account so i could answer your questions.
Alright, first of all.

1. Akai was shot. Then had the side of his face blown up. So, who says hat he couldn`t have had his memory erased? (as Jodie said.)
Back in the robbery case, akai didn`t reply. It could be, because he couldn`t remember anything.

2. Okiya is akai? In the last panel of chapter 700, we see Akai &Okiya. Both standing there. Asuming that he had his memory erased, we could say that the 2 people standing there weren`t the same person. And that the guy standing there, is, infact Akai.
Image
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Eve »

Hmmm... The reason Conan is so shocked could be:

a. Akai is suppose to be dead, like really dead dead, so the only reason he's here is that he's someone else.
b. Akai is suppose to play dead, but he's not playing dead.
c. Conan realized if Akai is alive, it could pose danger somehow

One thing for sure, Subaru is not Akai.

Argh..the author is killing me!  ???
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
Korn
Korn

Posts:
57

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Korn »

my theory :

Akai made a plan.. which conan is aware of.. that he would play dead and not show himself on public..

So conan, being aware of that! was wondering why he suddenly showed up there, hence he did that

SHOCKING FACE
Eve
Hiatus :P

Posts:
4651

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Eve »

Korn wrote: my theory :

Akai made a plan.. which conan is aware of.. that he would play dead and not show himself on public..

So conan, being aware of that! was wondering why he suddenly showed up there, hence he did that

SHOCKING FACE
I don't know, for some reason, I feel like I won't be satisfy if Akai simply just "survived", if he is indeed Alive, then I would need a plausible explanation, or else, it might be that he's DEAD, and someone is disguising as Akai
Image Image
[quote="朱砂泪"]
镜湖翠微低云垂佳人å¸
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: File 699: Why Do Conan Looked So Shocked...

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

Khinkhun wrote:
I don't know, for some reason, I feel like I won't be satisfy if Akai simply just "survived", if he is indeed Alive, then I would need a plausible explanation, or else, it might be that he's DEAD, and someone is disguising as Akai
If you want plausible theories about how Hidemi and Akai worked together to fake Akai's death then start reading here. The explanations go on for a couple pages.
Last edited by Chekhov MacGuffin on July 31st, 2009, 6:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply