Page 1 of 4

Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawing b

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 6:22 pm
by Detective Girl
Image
Image

Image
Image


Top two are Aono san's drawing,
and bottom two are by Sudo san.

Both two are considered as best Drawing Directors,(though, Aono san did quit years ago.)
but thier drawings are very different.
Aono san's drawing is more closer to Gosho sama's drawing...
sometimes he had drawn Haibara better than Gosho sama(I think)


Sudo san had worked from the 1st EP, and the longest staff member to work on DC.
He is in charge of MV, and his drawing is lot sharper than Gosho sama's.





Really, which kind of drawing do you like better?

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 6:37 pm
by KaitoKid0
aono

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 6:51 pm
by ranger
hmmm I can't really tell the difference honestly,

all I know is that there is a huge change in the artstyle compared with the older episodes and the newer ones (the first like 150, the head shapes were a lot rounder..and stuff, its hard to explain)

the newer artstyle is much more sharp, and it just looks better :p

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 7:33 pm
by TheBlind
You need more definitive screens as the ones provided only have small differences. Only thing I could point out was that Conan's jawline differed but that could of been because of the angle.

The guy who drew this is the one I like better....maybe.
Spoiler:
The one on the left with Ayumi, not the right.
Spoiler:
Image

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 8:01 pm
by AICHAN
TheBlind wrote: You need more definitive screens as the ones provided only have small differences. Only thing I could point out was that Conan's jawline differed but that could of been because of the angle.

The guy who drew this is the one I like better....maybe. The one on the left with Ayumi, not the right.
Spoiler:
Image
i like the style in the second pic with ayumi and ai!  for me this is a better design in DC episodes(the better style ;D) than the new design in the recent episodes!

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 8:02 pm
by kkslider5552000
who did the animation for the Kaze no Lalala OP? Because that person is the best.

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 10:37 pm
by kirite
Firstly it's important to remember that animation is a team work.  Many people work on one frame.  In the most basic setting someone will do background, a bunch of people will do the character moving and some people will be making sure that all the frames look the same drawing style :).

I'm a big fan of Aono-san's frames.  The lines were blended accordingly and have a thickness that remind me of manga lines with pen nib.  I'm also a fan of the colour theory and the proportions :).  Of course I would understand why it'll be difficult to HD.  So I guess The current frames with the sharp pen digital lines makes sense too (it's not as warm but that's how anime lines usual are nowadays).  

Personally I don't like how the art right now is very inconsistant between the frames..  There seems to be more distortions between frames resulting in really weird frames if you don't pause at the right place.

Thank you for the information <3

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 10:39 pm
by ranger
one thnig that always bugs me is that haibara's hair color constantly changes

oh yeah, whoever did the current opening (everlasting luv) and revive animation is my favorite, very good artwork

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 12th, 2009, 11:14 pm
by yukionna
Aono's Conan possesses a kind of extra badass-ness.

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 13th, 2009, 12:45 am
by bluekaitou1412
I'd say I liked both.

But if i really have to pick, it'll be Aono for Ran's drawing.

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 13th, 2009, 3:25 am
by Akonyl
aono I'd say.

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 14th, 2009, 12:59 am
by ccppfan
I really can't choose.... Aono-san's looks more like the manga style, but Sudo-san has sharper lines...

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 14th, 2009, 11:55 am
by Eve
ccppfan wrote: I really can't choose.... Aono-san's looks more like the manga style, but Sudo-san has sharper lines...
Who's drawing is it in 500+ ep? (I can't ever catch up to the credit and read XD*

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 14th, 2009, 12:16 pm
by Rellik
i like the artist(s) who drew episode 200 to around 400, it looks more like the manga

really hate the the drawings after episode 500

Re: Just Wondering, Do you like Aono san or Sudo san's drawi

Posted: August 14th, 2009, 12:56 pm
by Eve
Rellik wrote: i like the artist(s) who drew episode 200 to around 400, it looks more like the manga

really hate the the drawings after episode 500
yeah... but who though?  ???