Conan Only

[Wakarimashita]

Strictly speaking, she is not a murderer, but an accessory.

Strictly speaking, she states that she was at least a part of various murders above just having made the drug. So you don't really know she was only an accessory.

She's innocent until proven guilty.
Also, making poison is NOT a crime. Freedom of research...

She has admitted being involved in this research.
Making one, no. Continuing to make one knowing it's being used to kill, yes.

[L-]

Strictly speaking, she is not a murderer, but an accessory.

Exactly^

[Wakarimashita]

And you think Conan understands the motivations of accessories  ?

[Dus]

And you think Conan understands the motivations of accessories  ?

LOL

Well she doesn't really expect him to understand her motivation or forgive her anyway.

[L-]

We weren't even talking about that

[Wakarimashita]

And you think Conan understands the motivations of accessories  ?

LOL
That's all I have to say

Well she doesn't really expect him to understand her motivation or forgive her anyway.

Just trying to debate here.

I wouldn't be so categorical, remember episode 176 where she joins him because she wants him to stop calling her a murderer.

[Dus]

Yes, but she'd never expect him to sanction her actions.

[L-]

Yes, but she'd never expect him to sanction her actions.

It kinda looks like he does or else he wouldn't be friends with her in the first place would he?

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Yes, but she'd never expect him to sanction her actions.

It kinda looks like he does or else he wouldn't be friends with her in the first place would he?

Are you actually saying Conan is sanctioning the drug's use as as poison? You are off base. He may have forgiven her for being an accessory given the forcing nature of her circumstances, her statement that she never intended to make a poison, and the regret she has expressed, but Conan isn't going to pretend like her crimes never happened. That is not like Conan. Furthermore, she was going test it out on a human (Kiichirou Numabuchi) and she would have if he hadn't escaped. Haibara was very close to actually directly murdering someone.

[Akemi~chan]

huh?

[ProfParanoia]

Yes, but she'd never expect him to sanction her actions.

It kinda looks like he does or else he wouldn't be friends with her in the first place would he?

Are you actually saying Conan is sanctioning the drug's use as as poison? You are off base. He may have forgiven her for being an accessory given the forcing nature of her circumstances, her statement that she never intended to make a poison, and the regret she has expressed, but Conan isn't going to pretend like her crimes never happened. That is not like Conan. Furthermore, she was going test it out on a human (Kiichirou Numabuchi) and she would have if he hadn't escaped. Haibara was very close to actually directly murdering someone.

Also she had a list of people it was tested on and I'm sure numerous ones were like Kiichirou that didn't get away. So she probably did directly murder someone.

[L-]

Hmm I think you guys are forgetting this is a different type of murder but alright you guys seem deadset on this

[ProfParanoia]

Hmm I think you guys are forgetting this is a different type of murder but alright you guys seem deadset on this

As long as you don't have a Charlie Chan set-up it' okay to murder people.

[L-]

I have no idea what your talking about so I'm just going to smile and nod.

*smiles while nodding*

[ProfParanoia]

I have no idea what your talking about so I'm just going to smile and nod.

*smiles while nodding*

What part of her murder being different changes it?