Mafia Round 18: Jungle Bells (Town wins)

[Dus]

No it wasn't, it was in the Alps.

And the mystery role is totally Eisuke, disguised as Eisuke.

[Akonyl]

Is the other role going to be revealed before the start of the game? Because if not, I disagree with it just as much as the round 14 POs.

[Abs.]

Is the other role going to be revealed before the start of the game? Because if not, I disagree with it just as much as the round 14 POs.

Translation:  "It's okay though, I'll still be able to lynch Abs. with shoddy evidence."

[Dus]

Nope, won't be revealed, you can disagree as much as you want.

[Akonyl]

Is the other role going to be revealed before the start of the game? Because if not, I disagree with it just as much as the round 14 POs.

Translation:  "It's okay though, I'll still be able to lynch Abs. with shoddy evidence."

my evidence was actually pretty decent imo, I just wanted to see if by any chance I could get the BO to think that I actually was a BO/town lover and thus poison one of their own people :V

I also couldn't say the evidence in the thread anyway, because the evidence was basically hinged on knowing everyone's roles.

Nope, won't be revealed, you can disagree as much as you want.

srsly? I see absolutely no reason to do this.

[Eve]

Is the other role going to be revealed before the start of the game? Because if not, I disagree with it just as much as the round 14 POs.

^ This

Seriously Dus? you're not going to reveal "New Roles" so it'll be discuss?

[Dus]

If I'm revealing the role I might just as well exclude it, because it would make the role pointless if everyone knows about it beforehand. The phase change post may include some hints, but that's about it.

It doesn't have a new ability and doesn't share an item combination with other characters.

[Eve]

If I'm revealing the role I might just as well exclude it, because it would make the role pointless if everyone knows about it beforehand. The phase change post may include some hints, but that's about it.

It doesn't have a new ability and doesn't share an item combination with other characters.

..... Wait, I'm not getting you here, so a player MIGHT get chosen to play a role that has practically no ability? Or are you saying that this "role" is like a role that won't be played, but a role that'll just appear as a support to the phase post?

[Akonyl]

honestly, don't want to be a spoilsport, but I would say to not include it then.

It's basically like challenging someone who doesn't know the rules to a game of chess, teaching them what all the pieces except the queen can do, and then taking their queen with yours and going "oh, I didn't tell you, the queen can move as many spaces as she wants. I thought that'd spice things up". Sure, it's not the same thing exactly, as we're not playing against the GM, but the idea of playing a deduction based game without knowing what's possible is just not a good idea to me. 

Especially for the BO. :V

[nomemory]

Do we even know if the new role is BO or not? Perhaps it is Yoko?

[Eve]

I still don't see why you must not reveal it....? Why does revealing a role defeats the role's purpose? I mean other roles are revealed..... why not this one ?

mafia is a blindly groping game already, having a blind role is just not necessary... I think

[Kleene Onigiri]

No it wasn't, it was in the Alps.

And the mystery role is totally Eisuke, disguised as Eisuke.

I remember you refering to the role as "her" :x So, it's a female eisuke.

I also wonder what it is, and knowing about it would be better.
But it also depends on what Duslein plans D: So, maybe it's a 3rd party role? :V
And it's totally yoko, I tell you!

Dus also said, that with the new rules, the number of BOs won't be predictable. So, maybe it has to do something with that role? :V







pssst.... I want Yamamura T_T

[Dus]

Alright, I've revealed as much information as I felt I could without breaking the character. And I can't tell you why I can't tell you, obviously.

[Akonyl]

Do we even know if the new role is BO or not? Perhaps it is Yoko?

I wasn't saying it'd be a BO role necessarily, but that if it wasn't a BO role, it would be really bad for the BO. The fact that there's a role you don't know about alone makes planning difficult, whether or not it's a good role in reality, because the BO doesn't know that.

also:
"My estimated citizens"
I think you mean esteemed.

[Kleene Onigiri]

But that role is from DC, right?